Lamar Miller vs. Keenan Allen

[joekuhns11]

In a vacuum, KA for Lamar Miller. For team 3

[dazza]

Allen

[Goddard]

Keenan Allen

[saw061600]

Keenan. Should have 2-3+ years more production than Miller
Edit: make that 3-5

[dpham503]

Looks like you need WR depth, I would go Allen.

[Coogan Football]

If we did a start-up draft where we picked forum users that start way more threads for themselves instead of actually helping out others you'd be no later than my 1.05

[M-Dub]

If we did a start-up draft where we picked forum users that start way more threads for themselves instead of actually helping out others you'd be no later than my 1.05

That'd be a huge reach. You'd be better off just trading down for someone who says "core" instead of "corps" and a future 1st in the 2018 Shitty Poster draft.

[HughHoney]

Allen

[ManhattanProject]

As a Miller owner I was excited just reading that someone thinks this needed a post. But to your question, I'd go Allen.

[skip]

If there were a poll attached here, I'm probably one of the only votes for Miller. I don't think either player is a difference maker for a fantasy team but I would rather have the 3 down back for the next 3 seasons than Keenan who I view as a more replaceable asset.

[Spongehack]

I'd make that trade, but you would probably have to add to get him.

[joekuhns11]

If we did a start-up draft where we picked forum users that start way more threads for themselves instead of actually helping out others you'd be no later than my 1.05

If we did a startup for losing at life & being a waste of space you'd go 1.01!!!!!

[Coogan Football]

If we did a start-up draft where we picked forum users that start way more threads for themselves instead of actually helping out others you'd be no later than my 1.05

If we did a startup for losing at life & being a waste of space you'd go 1.01!!!!!

If we took a vote of people on here you would probably get your feelings hurt.

[onetwothree]

If there were a poll attached here, I'm probably one of the only votes for Miller. I don't think either player is a difference maker for a fantasy team but I would rather have the 3 down back for the next 3 seasons than Keenan who I view as a more replaceable asset.

3 down back for 3 years seems very optimistic and best case scenario for Miller while Keenan as a replaceable asset is probably worst case scenario and dismissive of a player that still carries a lot of trade value.

Actual is probably a lot closer to the middle with Miller retaining value for maybe 1-2 more seasons as the bigger share in a RBBC while Keenan settles in as a WR2 in PPR with some big games mixed in.

[scorpion]

Keenan