What should I give for Marshall?

[Kaz]

We recently completed our 16 team idp league, and this guy is listening to offers for Brandon Marshall. He says that he would like RB, LB, or QB. Draft picks in 2011 are also available to trade.

Start: 1 QB, 2 RB, 2 WR, 1 flx, 1 DT, 2 DE, 2 LB, 2 CB, 2 S, 1 K

My team

QB: E. Manning, Freeman
RB: Mendenhall, Stewart, Jackson, Blount
WR: Crabtree, Smith (NYG), Williams (TB), Gilyard, Nelson, Damian Williams
TE: John Carlson
DT: Babineux, Seymour,
DE: Tamba Hall, Shaun Ellis, Pierre-Paul, Connor Barwin, Carlos Dunlap
LB: Beason, Cushing, Curry, Maualuga, Navorro Bowman, Keenan Clayton
CB: Thomas, Joseph, Kyle Wilson, Griffin, Chris Cook
S: Polamalu, Babineaux, Manning, Stuckey

His team

QB: Palmer, Fitzpatrick
RB: F. Jones, Hardesty, Hamilton, L. Johnson
WR: Austin, Marshall, J. Jones, Burleson, Shipley, Robiske, Naanee
TE: Gates, Moaeki
DT: K. Williams
DE: Cole, Shaughnessy, A. Carter, L. English, A. Lane
LB: Fletcher, Barnett, S. Phillips, Dumervil, D. Butler
CB: Bodden, Greer, Samuel, Cason
S: Berry, Landry, Pool, Leonhard

[BeRanDone]

I don't see a way for you to let go of a QB or RB for Marshall without screwing up your team. I don't play IDP so I can't speak to the LB portion of this.

[andrewfroboy]

His WR seem pretty weak, can't see why he'd be trading Marshall, hard to see a trade happening there

[MARKinMI]

agreed, Marshall is a top 5 WR (imo) but you don't have anywhere close to the depth you need to pull off a trade.

[bdynomite]

Bad move for both teams honestly, neither of you have depth at the positions you'd have to give up. I am however assuming that "Jackson" is Brandon Jackson and not Steven Jackson, correct? Otherwise you'd have a trade right there.

[BradyT]

If its Steven Jackson, the I´d offer him for Marshall.. otherwise I dont see a trade happen.

[Kaz]

It's Fred Jackson.

[BradyT]

It's Fred Jackson.

I guess no chance then.

[bigcsr67]

Bad move for both teams honestly, neither of you have depth at the positions you'd have to give up. I am however assuming that "Jackson" is Brandon Jackson and not Steven Jackson, correct? Otherwise you'd have a trade right there.

I don't see it as that bad a move for either team. This is a 16 team league, so all of your perceptions about depth are a bit off. The team with Marshall also has Miles Austin. Those two guys on the same team in a 16 teamer is pretty good.

On that note, I don't know if I would give up one of your RBs to land a WR. You already have some good young guys, and I think you would be better off rolling with what you got for the time being.

[dlf_ericd]

I don't see it as that bad a move for either team. This is a 16 team league, so all of your perceptions about depth are a bit off. The team with Marshall also has Miles Austin. Those two guys on the same team in a 16 teamer is pretty good.

On that note, I don't know if I would give up one of your RBs to land a WR. You already have some good young guys, and I think you would be better off rolling with what you got for the time being.

This ^^^