Trade evaluation!

[haydn239]

Wondering what people think about this trade? 10 team .5 PPR start 2RB, 3WR

Smith, Kevin DET RB
Britt, Kenny TEN WR
Sims-Walker, Mike JAC WR

for

Brown, Ronnie MIA RB
Bess, Davone MIA WR
White, Roddy ATL WR

[nightmarion]

The Roddy side of this trade comes out significantly ahead. MSW is inconsistent, Britt, well who knows with the reports on him this offseason, and Smith will be playing behind Best.

Ronnie has been a top ten back when on the field. Bess may not be worth much at this point, but Roddy is obviously a top ten WR.

This one isn't even close IMO

[skip]

Roddy White is far and away the best player in this trade. You'd have to remove Brown from the deal entirely to try to make this happen. Not big fan of Brown, but he's an upgrade at this point to Smith.

[GridIronFavre]

Roddy side far and away. Without question he is the best player in the trade. Regardless of what you think of Ronnie Brown, he is a large upgrade over Kevin Smith also.

[Guppy CEO]

yeah, 2 huge upgrades vs 1 huge upgrade. it would be a terrible trade for the team giving up white/brown

[Steelersfan]

I love the Roddy side of the deal!

[haydn239]

Thanks...i'm the one trying to get roddy and this guy was trying to give me bess for k. smith so i countered with this just hoping for the best! Prob would throw in a 2011 1st to sweeten the pot if he declines as i have three at this point. Thanks for the feedback!

[BradyT]

I love the Roddy side of the deal!

Same here.. and it wins big time. Jahvid Best is the RB to own in DET... so Brown is easily an upgrade over K.smith.

Well.. and I dont have to say anything about what Roddy is doing for the overall value ins this trade.. and where its going....