Sutton or C. Ridley

[YouMightDieTryin]

I feel like this shouldn't even be close, but in my head it is. Talk me down from the ledge please.

[Gator Sens]

Still Ridley for me. I think he is back and playing again even if its next year. Hold the best asset in dynasty.

[murphysxm]

I really, really like Sutton and this is very close to me. I think gun to the head I would rather have Ridley still though

[CooperCrush]

I love both players, but would still prefer Ridley

[gpaok]

I see the reason for the question but I think Ridley is still better when playing. I think Sutton is in the Amari Cooper level where he is a huge boom or bust player. I would still prefer Cooper but they are close for me.

Also note Sutton’s good games have been with no other Wr due to injuries.

[Valhalla]

Also note Sutton’s good games have been with no other Wr due to injuries.

This speaks more to the QB play to me than the WR talent. If it were WR talent, then Sutton should be getting shut down when the defensive backs can focus more on him...but he isn't shut down. Target him and he makes plays.

I'll go against the crowd here and say I want Sutton, because it seems Ridley is a future play anyways (as in next year) and Sutton is both actually playable right now AND potentially in a better QB situation next year (and Ridley's QB situation just MIGHT go the opposite way).

[logan_roy]

Delayed reply, but easily Ridley for me still. Ridley’s upside remains greater than Sutton and frankly Sutton has been a huge disappointment this entire season

[millworkguy]

Sorry but mental illness is not a joke. Is he bipolar, suicidal, anxiety or depressed???? Ridley is not on my radar (esp in my salary cap leagues where he is 6-10% of the cap). I'd likely buy for a mid 3rd, otherwise I'm taking all the risk here imo.

Give me Sutton all day long, and let's hope he improves with better supporting cast.