Keenan Allen vs. Jarvis Landry

[Gandalf]

Keenan Allen vs. Jarvis Landry recently came up for debate in my main dynasty league (0.5 PPR) and after digging it, I realized these two players are a lot closer than previously expected. Over the last three years, Keenan has averaged roughly 100 catches for 1,200 yards while Jarvis has hovered around 80 catches for 1,000 yards, give or take. However, their end of season point differences are generally within 15-45 points of each other. Specifically, there was a 22 point difference in 2017, 44 point difference in 2018, and 10 point difference in 2019, all in favor of Keenan.

To me, I see Keenan as a low-end WR1 with high end upside. Jarvis on the other hand is a consistent WR2 with low end WR1 upside. Jarvis is slightly younger with a slightly better situation.

What do you all think? How big of a difference is there between Keenan and Jarvis? I originally thought it was about a late first difference but am thinking it's probably closer to a mid second round difference.

[Packerland]

In a startup i'm currently in Allen went 43 overall and Landry went 62. I think a mid second is probably relatively close, I would try that.

[Gator Sens]

Agreed, Landry and a 2nd seems fair to close the gap to Allen.