Sanders or Jacobs going forward?

[gunfrees]

Having a discussion with my league mates on who will probably be the better fantasy producer to have on your team going forward. Thoughts?

[lukkynumber13]

Sanders has all the hype in the world right now, mainly because Philly hasn’t added anyone at RB while the Raiders have added Booker and Bowden, but I still would want Jacobs in a vacuum. The better football player, IMO.

Sanders is a better version of Tevin Coleman (which isn’t a bad thing, but I don’t think he’s going to be a rock star RB1 for the next 3 years)

[dirkey]

Jacobs pretty easily for me.

[FantasyFreak]

Jacobs pretty easily for me.

X2

[AussieMate]

Prefered Sanders last year so nothing has changed for me, so far Philly is yet to add another competing back and I'm not sure the Raiders are ever going to pass Jacobs the ball unfortunately (as he is a very good pass catcher).

[Gator Sens]

Jacobs

[joeya2001]

Sanders has all the hype in the world right now, mainly because Philly hasn’t added anyone at RB while the Raiders have added Booker and Bowden, but I still would want Jacobs in a vacuum. The better football player, IMO.

Sanders is a better version of Tevin Coleman (which isn’t a bad thing, but I don’t think he’s going to be a rock star RB1 for the next 3 years)

here comes Carlos Hyde!

[AussieMate]

Sanders has all the hype in the world right now, mainly because Philly hasn’t added anyone at RB while the Raiders have added Booker and Bowden, but I still would want Jacobs in a vacuum. The better football player, IMO.

Sanders is a better version of Tevin Coleman (which isn’t a bad thing, but I don’t think he’s going to be a rock star RB1 for the next 3 years)

here comes Carlos Hyde!

If that were to happen I would change my vote to Jacobs as they were both very close for me, I will say that Hyde doesn't scare me in the slightest but it would be enough to move Jacobs up.

also where are my Sanders fans at? plenty of votes but only Jacobs fans have showed their face so far!!!!

[MFundercover]

Sanders had a better rookie year and his organization is showing they have confidence in him. It's Sanders.

[never_punts]

Jacobs for me but the gap isn't huge. I think Sanders is really talented and it'll be hard to keep him from getting snaps

[dirkey]

Sanders had a better rookie year and his organization is showing they have confidence in him. It's Sanders.

He'd a better year because he played more games. Jacobs missed 3 games and was 9 points behind in half point ppr. Not sure how sanders had the better year if I'm honest.

[MFundercover]

Sanders had a better rookie year and his organization is showing they have confidence in him. It's Sanders.

He'd a better year because he played more games. Jacobs missed 3 games and was 9 points behind in half point ppr. Not sure how sanders had the better year if I'm honest.

Sanders: 179 attempts for 818 yards, 50 receptions for 509 yards. 5.8 yards per touch. 6 TDs

Jacobs: 242 attempts for 1150 yards, 20 receptions for 166 yards. 5.0 yards per touch. 7 TDs

It's not because he played more games. He was more efficient and productive on less touches. He had a better season.

[dirkey]

Sanders had a better rookie year and his organization is showing they have confidence in him. It's Sanders.

He'd a better year because he played more games. Jacobs missed 3 games and was 9 points behind in half point ppr. Not sure how sanders had the better year if I'm honest.

Sanders: 179 attempts for 818 yards, 50 receptions for 509 yards. 5.8 yards per touch. 6 TDs

Jacobs: 242 attempts for 1150 yards, 20 receptions for 166 yards. 5.0 yards per touch. 7 TDs

It's not because he played more games. He was more efficient and productive on less touches. He had a better season.

Interesting. Fair enough.

I look at things through a fantasy lens. Jacobs was 14th in points per game in our league, sanders 22nd.

[MFundercover]

He'd a better year because he played more games. Jacobs missed 3 games and was 9 points behind in half point ppr. Not sure how sanders had the better year if I'm honest.

Sanders: 179 attempts for 818 yards, 50 receptions for 509 yards. 5.8 yards per touch. 6 TDs

Jacobs: 242 attempts for 1150 yards, 20 receptions for 166 yards. 5.0 yards per touch. 7 TDs

It's not because he played more games. He was more efficient and productive on less touches. He had a better season.

Interesting. Fair enough.

I look at things through a fantasy lens. Jacobs was 14th in points per game in our league, sanders 22nd.

Considering the touches are going to be much closer going forward, I dont see any argument to be made for Jacobs except for draft capital. Its definitely Sanders right now.

[dirkey]

Sanders: 179 attempts for 818 yards, 50 receptions for 509 yards. 5.8 yards per touch. 6 TDs

Jacobs: 242 attempts for 1150 yards, 20 receptions for 166 yards. 5.0 yards per touch. 7 TDs

It's not because he played more games. He was more efficient and productive on less touches. He had a better season.

Interesting. Fair enough.

I look at things through a fantasy lens. Jacobs was 14th in points per game in our league, sanders 22nd.

Considering the touches are going to be much closer going forward, I dont see any argument to be made for Jacobs except for draft capital. Its definitely Sanders right now.

Ah, I hear ya. I actually don't expect the touches to be closer, Pedersen has always been rbbc, I expect them to pick someone up in FA. They were very vocal about missing Howard down the stretch.

I guess time will tell! I don't own either anywhere, so no skin off my nose