Jerry jeudy vs tyreke hill

[Dblackburn10]

Who would you rather have moving forward?

Thanks

[FantasyFreak]

If I didn't have a personal philosophy not to roster Hill, it's Hill and not close. Objectively, as talents and situations, it's not even remotely close. It's Hill based on that. Even with Hill's off field issues, he should net you more than a college prospect that is not even unanimously considered the best player at his position this year.

[Valhalla]

Yeah this is Hill for sure...even in a complete rebuild. The only way it's Jeudy is if you have an internal conflict with rostering Hill.

[Gator Sens]

Hill very easily. Jeudy has a ways to go before/if he is ever in Hills league.

[Mjvb5]

seconding the hill and not close for hill unless you personally refuse to own hill which I respect

[Goddard]

Since the question is being asked, I'm assuming OP has no personal conflict with rostering Hill. As already stated, this is Hill and not close right now.

[murphysxm]

I love Jeudy and his future, I don't own Hill anywhere because I don't like the human he is. Even I can't take the Jeudy side here.

[DYNASTY BALLA$]

Hill for me as well. With the unanimous consensus being Hill so far, the question should be amended to:

Hill = Jeudy + ???

I'd say Jeudy (if a lock) + 1.05 pick

Personally, I'd need 2 highly probably successes to gamble giving Hill away

[Valhalla]

Hill for me as well. With the unanimous consensus being Hill so far, the question should be amended to:

Hill = Jeudy + ???

I'd say Jeudy (if a lock) + 1.05 pick

Personally, I'd need 2 highly probably successes to gamble giving Hill away

Agreed

[Mjvb5]

Hill for me as well. With the unanimous consensus being Hill so far, the question should be amended to:

Hill = Jeudy + ???

I'd say Jeudy (if a lock) + 1.05 pick

Personally, I'd need 2 highly probably successes to gamble giving Hill away

I wouldn’t really want a pick with jeudy, I’d be looking for a guy like Sutton, Aaron Jones, Golladay type

[Blueboy]

I'll be the first to go out on a limb and say Jeudy

[Mjvb5]

I'll be the first to go out on a limb and say Jeudy

Would you mind giving your reasoning? I’m curious as other than off field concerns I don’t really see a case for jeudy. If it is founded on off field issues than I totally get that too

[Blueboy]

I'll be the first to go out on a limb and say Jeudy

Would you mind giving your reasoning? I’m curious as other than off field concerns I don’t really see a case for jeudy. If it is founded on off field issues than I totally get that too

Yes, off field concerns would be the primary reason. I also think Jeudy is a very safe bet to return high end WR2 numbers, which with his age would make him a very valuable asset. I think it's realistic that they'll hold similar value in two years, and I'll jump at taking that risk especially if I can get Jeudy+ for Hill.

[megager]

Hill easily. Has a ceiling Jeudy will just never hit.

I love Jeudy but I think Jeudys NFL career could be Robert woods level. Now that's really good but it's not something I'd be willing to sacrifice Hill for. But if you get that in a rookie draft for the next 6-8 years it's still very valuable.
Of course if he goes to the Jets....it might not even reach that level
.