Dynasty League Football Forum

Give your reasons besides draft pedigree

I'll say Meredith. I am biased though as I have stock in Meredith though and none in white.

My main reasoning is due to Cams ability to stay healthy and when he needed to step up he did so against some decent secondaries.

I'll say Meredith. I am biased though as I have stock in Meredith though and none in white.

My main reasoning is due to Cams ability to stay healthy and when he needed to step up he did so against some decent secondaries.

I wasn't overly impressed with Meredith but it's a good situation for him and he did flash a few times last year.

White has shown an inability to stay on the field and didn't do anything special with his chances last year. It's do or die time for him in Chicago this year.

I'm rooting for Cam because I have a share, but feels like a toss up really.

Voting like a toss-up so far at 5-5

Interesting voting thus far.

Meredith for me. He's actually produced.

Goddard wrote: ↑Sun May 14, 2017 1:33 pm Meredith for me. He's actually produced.

Yes...x2

I own both as I traded for White at the end of last year.

Meredith didn't impress me that much last year but got him off waivers before he blew up and he helped in a 20 team league.

White hasn't been able to stay healthy and I question his mental ability to play football. And his ability to run routes.

In the end I think it's pretty even with White having the physical advantage and Meredith the Mental and Durability advantage.

If we are grading solely on talent, White has the edge. But I'm voting for the WR I trust to stay healthy and produce. That's not White.

Meredith for me. But I think white is a paper towel. I like white for virtually free though

I think it's very likely the Bears draft a WR high next year, making neither the better long-term choice. This year, I lean towards Meredith as he's actually done something.

I don't particularly like either in the midst of the Chicago rebuild. Both will have their Rookie contracts up before the QB sitution is truly settled.

I went Cam though. Give me the more likely one to produce something in the middle of that mess, because he's more likely to be healthy.

I listened to an interview about a month or so back of Ryan Pace (Bears' GM) who glowed about Meredith - his ability, his maturity; it was telling. When discussing White, the tone turned more to "he's got a lot to prove", "he has to stay healthy" and the like. I've put plenty of chips into Meredith for this year being a very cheap, young WR2 who could rise in value very quickly with a couple of weeks of production that mirror his better games last year. That team will be playing from behind a lot - obtaining White from anyone who drafted him for less than what you can get Meredith for will be tough.

Do you prefer Jordan Matthews or Keenan Allen? Not exact comps, but I see Meredith as a middling flex or low-end WR2, a non-exciting player but good depth with steady production like Matthews. White is the swing for the fences top-10 upside with might never give you a 16-game season like Allen.