Ellington vs Stewart

[Kossack]

Each has a rookie that many envision will earn snaps. Each has legitimate or perceived injury concerns.

Who ya got with 2015 production specifically in mind?

[cd6696]

I like Stewart over Ellington and his rookie is cheaper to obtain

[theone]

I have them fairly even in standard scoring with Ellington having a significant edge in PPR settings due to Ellington being used a lot in the passing game. This also gives Ellington a higher weekly floor.

[Gametime675]

Both have injury concerns but I think Stewart will produce more on the field. There is also no chance that Artis-Payne is pushing a healthy Stewart and I honestly think Tolbert would be next in line anyways. I predict, at best, that Ellington is in a 50/50 timeshare by mid-season. He might actually lose receiving work first because Johnson is an exceptional talent in the receiving game.

[Steelersfan]

Ellington in PPR leagues.

[Kossack]

So,... Considering the question at hand pertains to my last keeper decision in a .5 ppr league it's a dead heat. Hopefully some one will pull away with some more votes.

[ddog2303]

I honestly think the guy you keep has everything to do with what the rest of your RB depth chart looks like. Artis-Payne would come much cheaper (if you wanted to grab a back up plan) than David Johnson so Stewart makes sense if that's your goal. But, if you are heavy on older RBs and light on younger backs, I'd keep Ellington. Both are highly likely to get hurt. So I really think the overall age of your RBs as a collective unit should probably dictate your decision.

[Bo Jackson]

Stewart