Coaching Carousel

[Pullo Vision]

Mike McCarthy to Dallas. Thoughts on the fantasy impact?

[Pac_Eddy]

Mike McCarthy to Dallas. Thoughts on the fantasy impact?

I think they'll continue to be an above average real life team, winning the division half the time. Probably stay about the same level as they are now for fantasy purposes.

It will be interesting to see how well McCarthy likes having Jerry Jones micromanage him. If they're winning, great, but when things are going bad, it'll be ugly.

[whaley88]

Panthers apparently stole rhule from the giants.

[Jigga94]

Mike McCarthy to Dallas. Thoughts on the fantasy impact?

I don't think it does much. Dak / Amari deals will have more impact directly for fantasy

[Cameron Giles]

Mike McCarthy to Dallas. Thoughts on the fantasy impact?

Statistically, I'm not sure it does anything for Dallas' offensive players. They all had big years. Dak almost threw for 5000, they had two 1100+ yd WRs and a 1300 yd RB. Not sure how it gets any better than that. I'd argue there will be regression.

[YouMightDieTryin]

Giants hiring Joe Judge as HC. Does this push them to take a WR at 1.4?

[Friction]

Panthers apparently stole rhule from the giants.

Can $60 million for a college coach be stealing?? A hot name, but not necessarily a BIG name, if that means much. You are right though, it seems like the Giants would be the ones for him.

[YouMightDieTryin]

I'd consider it a steal if it were Urban or Riley. Best of luck to Rhule, but I'm not holding my breath.

I wonder why Les Miles has never garnered any interest as an NFL HC. He fits that quirky McVay vibe where you just never know what he'll call next.

[bjd5211]

Urban Meyer would be a disaster at the NFL level, he's a big name but he's not a fit for the NFL game. He's a really good coach don't get me wrong, but what really makes him special in college is recruiting, which doesn't exist in the NFL.

[YouMightDieTryin]

Urban Meyer would be a disaster at the NFL level, he's a big name but he's not a fit for the NFL game. He's a really good coach don't get me wrong, but what really makes him special in college is recruiting, which doesn't exist in the NFL.

There is a bit of recruiting done in the NFL to a lesser extent. A certain coach hired might attract FA better than others. Likewise no one in their right mind is going to Miami unless they want Jan/Feb off every year.

[Valhalla]

Urban Meyer would be a disaster at the NFL level, he's a big name but he's not a fit for the NFL game. He's a really good coach don't get me wrong, but what really makes him special in college is recruiting, which doesn't exist in the NFL.

Jarvis Landry and Baker Mayfield recruited Odell Beckham...

[bjd5211]

Urban Meyer would be a disaster at the NFL level, he's a big name but he's not a fit for the NFL game. He's a really good coach don't get me wrong, but what really makes him special in college is recruiting, which doesn't exist in the NFL.

Jarvis Landry and Baker Mayfield recruited Odell Beckham...

Ok? Good luck building an entire NFL roster through recruiting. That was Urbans biggest advantage and strength over other college coaches.

[Jigga94]

Urban Meyer would be a disaster at the NFL level, he's a big name but he's not a fit for the NFL game. He's a really good coach don't get me wrong, but what really makes him special in college is recruiting, which doesn't exist in the NFL.

Jarvis Landry and Baker Mayfield recruited Odell Beckham...

Ok? Good luck building an entire NFL roster through recruiting. That was Urbans biggest advantage and strength over other college coaches.

I'm with you here. Can't just recruit a bunch of big name all stars. Works in basketball where they all go to play with friends but the salary cap is trickier with more players needed in the NFL. The cheaper role players are just as important. Not too many coaches are going to be a difference maker in contract negotiations. Some might, but I've never really noticed

Besides, that Odell thing hasn't quite worked out so well

[Pullo Vision]

Regression for Zeke is exactly my concern- Garrett was a conservative play caller and he may have leaned to the run game. A less conservative coach might choose to air it out more- was McCarthy a conservative coach? Could Prescott guide an offense that wasn't based on the run?

Also, how could a coach of McCarthy's experience affect the Prescott negotiations? Will he be willing to stay for less money?

[ericanadian]

Regression for Zeke is exactly my concern- Garrett was a conservative play caller and he may have leaned to the run game. A less conservative coach might choose to air it out more- was McCarthy a conservative coach? Could Prescott guide an offense that wasn't based on the run?

Also, how could a coach of McCarthy's experience affect the Prescott negotiations? Will he be willing to stay for less money?

McCarthy was pretty conservative, but had Aaron Rodgers and never had a back at the level of Zeke.