Thoughts on this superflex deal?

[auggiedoggies]

12 teams, PPR, 4 pts passing TD, 6 pts all other TD

Dalton/Alshon/2016 3rd

for

Eli/Jordy/2016 1st

[Fantasyfanatic11]

Tough call, its pretty close for me.

I view Jordy>Alshon right now but Alshon is a lot younger.
Eli and Dalton is a wash for me, they are both capable of putting up solid numbers and both capable of being very inconsistent. (However Dalton is younger, so if I had to choose id take dalton)
And obviously the 1st is way better than the 3rd.

It would help to know the makeup of your team to decide which side is better.

[Detroitcity]

I think Dalton= Eli and Jordy = Alshon, so give me the side with the 1st

[auggiedoggies]

Tough call, its pretty close for me.

I view Jordy>Alshon right now but Alshon is a lot younger.
Eli and Dalton is a wash for me, they are both capable of putting up solid numbers and both capable of being very inconsistent. (However Dalton is younger, so if I had to choose id take dalton)
And obviously the 1st is way better than the 3rd.

It would help to know the makeup of your team to decide which side is better.

I think I've got the potential to be a contender this year. Here's my squad (post trade, I completed the trade and got the Eli side). We start 1Q/2R/2W/1T/2F/1super flex

Wilson/Eli/McCown
Sankey/Vereen/Zo/West/Khiry/Bradshaw/Gerhard
Calvin/Jordy/DJax/Keenan/VJax/Edelman/Floyd/Jennings/Lafell/Marquess Wilson/Toon/Albert Wilson
Jimmy Graham/Escobar/Fiedorowicz/Gillmore

So, maybe I'm not a contender after typing it out...I'm not sure? I think I can move some WR depth for another RB possibly, but other than that I feel pretty good. I also have 3 2016 1sts and 2 2nds

[invisibulman]

Eli > Dalton
Jordy > Alshon
1st > 3rd.

Someone mis-valued the players. Picks should have been reversed.

[Detroitcity]

[/quote}

I think I've got the potential to be a contender this year. Here's my squad (post trade, I completed the trade and got the Eli side). We start 1Q/2R/2W/1T/2F/1super flex

Wilson/Eli/McCown
Sankey/Vereen/Zo/West/Khiry/Bradshaw/Gerhard
Calvin/Jordy/DJax/Keenan/VJax/Edelman/Floyd/Jennings/Lafell/Marquess Wilson/Toon/Albert Wilson
Jimmy Graham/Escobar/Fiedorowicz/Gillmore

So, maybe I'm not a contender after typing it out...I'm not sure? I think I can move some WR depth for another RB possibly, but other than that I feel pretty good. I also have 3 2016 1sts and 2 2nds[/quote]


Not sure you are a contender right now as it stands, but yeah I would try to move either Keenan, Edelman, Lafell, or Floyd (assuming its Michael) for a RB

[Seventy5]

I prefer the Eli side personally, but multiple pieces could go either way depending on ones values on them. I break it down like:

Eli > Dalton
Jordy=Alshon (although, if I had to chose between the two Id take Alshon)
1st >> 3rd

QB: Russell Wilson
QB: Eli Manning
WR: Calvin Johnson
WR: Jordy Nelson
TE: Jimmy Graham
FL: Keenan Allen - DeSean Jackson - Julien Edelman - Vincent Jackson - Michael Floyd
RB: ?
RB: Shane Vereen - Bishop Sankey - Terrance West - Khiry/Bradshaw

...is definitely good enough to compete. It wont win any signature contests, but Russell/Eli/Megatron/Jordy/Graham is more than enough to compete. Find a solution to your RB position and you're set for this year.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Eli > Dalton
Jordy > Alshon
1st > 3rd.

Someone mis-valued the players. Picks should have been reversed.

This. I'd keep Eli and Jordy.

[auggiedoggies]

Eli > Dalton
Jordy > Alshon
1st > 3rd.

Someone mis-valued the players. Picks should have been reversed.

This. I'd keep Eli and Jordy.

Sorry, should have been more clear. I already completed the trade, I received the Eli/Jordy side

[knotts4372]

Eli > Dalton
Jordy > Alshon
1st > 3rd.

Someone mis-valued the players. Picks should have been reversed.

this. someone def made a real bad trade

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

Eli > Dalton
Jordy > Alshon
1st > 3rd.

Someone mis-valued the players. Picks should have been reversed.

This. I'd keep Eli and Jordy.

Sorry, should have been more clear. I already completed the trade, I received the Eli/Jordy side

Oh, well then nvm. Good for you.