Who won this trade? {Poll}

[Ioverpayforrookies]

It's for team 1 in my sig, haven't updated players yet. 2TE/3RB starting league.

Team 1 receives: Jimmy Graham, Alshon Jeffery, Isaiah Crowell, 2.6
Team 2 receives: Dez Bryant, Jordan Cameron, Jeremy Hill, Jarvis Landry

[trvrpryc]

It is somewhat close but I think the team receiving Dez wins.. Especially if Cameron returns to form.

[Fantasyfanatic11]

I view it as:

Dez>Alshon
Cameron<Graham
Hill>Crowell
Landry>2.6

Dez side by a lot for me, regardless if Cameron returns to form or not. If he leaves cleveland and lands in a good spot then it makes the trade even better for Dez side.

[AOS2323]

I like the Dez side by a lot. Dez is among the elite of the elite, Hill and Landry are young but already putting up numbers and Cameron could turn into a lot more than he's been. Losing Graham sucks but Crowell is still unproven and on Clevelands crap offense and personally, I think Jeffery is going to score lower next year.

[Ron_Y]

Love the feedback, im the team giving up Dez (Team 1 below)!

My viewpoint:

in a 2TE league, if i can have Julio/Alshon/Sammy as my starting WR's with Jimmy Graham as one of my two TE's, that is worth losing out on Dez.

I see

Dez > Alshon (finished as WR's 4 and 10 last year)
Cameron <<< Graham
Hill > Crowell
Landry > 2.6

Overall i feel like i did give up a bit, but totally worth it as a contending team who has been lacking an elite TE for a long time, and i still get to keep 3 really good WR's starting.

Just my 2 cents

[invisibulman]

Team 1 receives: Jimmy Graham, Alshon Jeffery, Isaiah Crowell, 2.6
Team 2 receives: Dez Bryant, Jordan Cameron, Jeremy Hill, Jarvis Landry

Dez > Graham
Hill <<< Jeffrey
Landry > Crowell
Cameron = 2.6

Pretty even IMO.

[WhatWouldDitkaDo]

In general, the Dez side won. BUT, in a 2TE league, I lean toward the Graham side.

[Ron_Y]

In general, the Dez side won. BUT, in a 2TE league, I lean toward the Graham side.

Yeah, in a nuthsell that is pretty much what my conclusion is. I'm happy to have Graham, sad to see Dez go.

[kmbryant09]

Here's my breakdown:

Graham / Jeffrey >> Dez / Hill

Sure, Cameron / Landry probably have more value than Crowell / 2.06 - but that's chump change when getting 2 studs in Graham and Jeffrey.

I know Hill's value is pretty high right now, but that just makes him a good sell-high candidate.

[Ioverpayforrookies]

And i'm obviously the team receiving Dez.

I'll be honest, Graham pissed me off last season with his couple of goose egg games. Those games, I didn't lose by many points so even if he had scored maybe 10 points instead of 0, I probably would've made the playoffs.

I see most votes are favoring my side, but I tend to lean toward it being more even. Like my trade partner said in his post above, he now has a starting WR core of Julio, Watkins, and Jeffery. I happen to own the 1.1 and plan on drafting Gurley, so my starting RBs become McCoy, Gurley, and J. Hill. I think we both did well with this trade.

Thanks for the feedback everyone!

[Ron_Y]

And i'm obviously the team receiving Dez.

I'll be honest, Graham pissed me off last season with his couple of goose egg games. Those games, I didn't lose by many points so even if he had scored maybe 10 points instead of 0, I probably would've made the playoffs.

I see most votes are favoring my side, but I tend to lean toward it being more even. Like my trade partner said in his post above, he now has a starting WR core of Julio, Watkins, and Jeffery. I happen to own the 1.1 and plan on drafting Gurley, so my starting RBs become McCoy, Gurley, and J. Hill. I think we both did well with this trade.

Thanks for the feedback everyone!

No, just thank me for my feedback.