Alshon+ for Graham+

[cdubbaya]

Need some advice for this offer:

Get:
Alshon
Gronk

Give:
Graham
Benjamin
Morris
Wright

Worth giving up that lineup for Alshon and Gronk? Looking at long time value as I'm in the playoffs this year but likely won't get far.

Trade deadline is Wednesday.

Thanks!

[Chandler Bing]

Alshon and Gronk easy

[dblj1199]

Too me Graham and Gronk are equal. So it is Alshon vs the other 3. You have small starting line up requirements, but I don't see Alshon being worth the other three, I think you lose out here. I'm passing on the deal.

[YusufRafle]

Gronk and Alshon for me too. Especially in a 2 WR with 1 Flex league.
Gronk>Graham
Alshon>Benjamin, Morris, Wright

[MichaelScarn]

Give me Alshon and Gronk all day.

[kiddragonsoft]

I'm on the Graham side. Your RB2 prob should be Alfred. If you make this trade you really don't have an RB2. And he's one of the few non rbbc rb so I think he's worth a decent amount.

[wildabeast49]

Id go Alshon Gronk without taking a second thought.

[sloth8u]

i wouldnt give alfy and wright to pick up those 2. your splitting hairs....

[DynastyDynasty]

I'd hold on Graham, Benjamin, Wright & Morris. I also think Graham and Gronk are essentially equal. Alshon isn't a big enough upgrade from Benjamin to pay Wright and Morris to get him. Wright is fairly solid and will get better whenever TEN solidifies their QB position. And I will echo what another poster said about Morris, there aren't too many non RBBC backs out there any more. I'd rather wait and see if he gets a new head coach and/or OC in the coming years. Gruden looks like a joke to me. If he does, he may just jump back into the top 12 RBs. Alshon is tempting, but I think you're using too much recency bias on Graham. He hasn't been as hot lately, whereas Gronk is the #1 TE this season. I bet you next season Graham still has a higher ADP, and he has just as good a shot next season to finish TE #1 as Gronk.

[cdubbaya]

I figured this would be pretty split. You're right I wouldn't have a clear RB2 although Mason is a decent fill in this year. I just don't value RBs much at all.

I also have some young WR depth Matthews and Adams so I'm not concerned about losing Benjamin and Wright. I see it as selling Benjamin high.

Gronk vs Graham is where I'm torn.

Thanks for the responses. I'm not sure what to do yet.

[maxhyde]

I would hold but I don't think Alshon is light years ahead of Benjamin...certainly not Morris and Wright ahead

[Rosenbluu]

Gronk/Alshon for me..

[Diti51]

If its a PPR, then I would not make the deal as Wright value goes up substantially while Morris value declines slightly.

I think the deal is close, but still think you are giving up a lot of depth and solid players.

Gronk > Graham this year. but if Gronk injured again and Graham healthy, I am hating this deal in 12 months.

Alshon vs KWright, Alf and Benjamin?

Benjamin value high now with volume which likely won't be better, but actually worse next year. Gotta figure they get Cam more weapons.
Agree with prior poster that Alf one of few RB not in RBBC.

I would do deal, but pull out Alf or KWright (if PPR) and see if he will do deal.