Hows this trade sound?

[AOS2323]

I GIVE UP- Megatron, Tre Mason, Tim Wright, 2015 2nd rd pick

HE GIVES UP- G. Bernard, Jeremy Hill, C. Patterson, J Witten

thoughts?????

[wolfepackage]

Sounds terrible to me. Not near enough for mega.

[cane]

i would take mega but i dont think its terrible. depends how gio and patterson develop. i like that both hill and gio are in there.

[WelkerTexasRanger]

I'd keep Calvin Johnson personally. Unless I'm getting a proven upper tier player back then I wouldn't consider a deal. Bernard and Patterson have lots of upside but neither has proven enough to be considered elite players.

[dblj1199]

I'm passing on this. Not enough for Calvin, not even close.

[BuckeyeNation]

Way too much risk in return for Calvin.

[ginganinjaKB]

Not enough for Mega at all for me

[chucksters]

I am much higher on Cordarrelle Patterson than are most but he's a player who scores better in certain formats than in others.
In my estimation he's the best physical specimen in the NFL and he's got an offensive coach who is going to manufacturer touches so there's a lot to like; I wouldn't bet against a Top 10 finish in many scoring formats.

Tre Mason is a warm body. Tim Wright is JAG.

This trade is reasonable but given other comments here, and the subjective nature of valuation in fantasy, I'd try to eek out a little more for Megatron. Could you move up in the draft instead of giving the 2nd rounder? Something like you give a third and he gives a second? Or you give a second and he gives a first?

Good luck.