Huge trade need input

[krash1990]

Was offered this trade in 16 team ppr league. Start 2 rbs 4 wr

Give: Doug Martin, Andre Ellington, Stephan Taylor, Emmanuel Sanders, Kyle Rudolph

Get: Marshawn Lynch, Calvin Johnson, 2014 3rd rd rookie

[MR ROURKE]

I would pass, but I think most people are too high on Calvin. So, take my decline with a grain of salt.

16 teams means you need quanity of good players to win rather than everything invested into a stud.

[markeclipse]

I'd pass too. As previous poster stated - 16 team league you need the depth, and you're trading 4 younger starters for 2 aging players. Short term I can see this being a solid move... but long term, I think it could be terrible.

[krash1990]

Nope I actually felt the same way I just wanted to make sure I wasnt making the wrong choice. In a deep league when them bye weeks hit it gets rough...

[nation31]

I would make the trade- I understand the note about 16 team leagues; but you are giving up 4 guys who might produce a total of 400 PPR points this season and Martin for Calvin (who might get close to 400 PPR points himself) and Lynch who will have a better season than Martin.

I am also not a Martin believer. I would need to see your actual roster to give a better answer on this one-but I am leaning towards the Calvin side right now.

[krash1990]

Qb stafford
Rb martin Ellington
Wrs julio sanders boykin jerricho cotchery
Te rudolph
Flex pitta
Must start 2 rbs and 4 wrs

[MR ROURKE]

your team is fine for a 16 team league, don't give away your future for the uncertainty of Lynch and going all in on a stud like Calvin. Lynch could do something to be suspended at any time and we don't even know where he'll be next year.

I like the scheme change for Rudolph. Hoping this is PPR and that makes Ellington good at your RB2. Sanders is a decent WR2 for you. Your supposed to have some holes in a 16 team league.

[nation31]

after checking out the lineup=i agree with everyone else-you should stay put.

[heyfeefellskee]

Was offered this trade in 16 team ppr league. Start 2 rbs 4 wr

Give: Doug Martin, Andre Ellington, Stephan Taylor, Emmanuel Sanders, Kyle Rudolph

Get: Marshawn Lynch, Calvin Johnson, 2014 3rd rd rookie

I love Calvin, but you have some solid talent waiting on your roster.

[joekuhns11]

Absolutely do not accept. Marshawn only has 1 or maybe 2 years left. Calvin won't be an elite receiver for too many more years