Jennings or Roberts

[Flying Ninja Monkey]

In a vacuum, which side for 12 team, Standard PPR?

Rashad Jennings and 2.11

or

Andre Roberts and 2.06

[maxhyde]

roberts 2.06

[Chandler Bing]

Jennings

[??Droppedballs??]

Jennings

[bigefat]

Roberts!
Giant's OL still sucks!

[BuckeyeNation]

Ill take Jennings. I seriously question high useful RG3's 3rd/4th target is going to be.

[Water Buffalo]

Kind of depends on team situation honestly. I could see the picks being the most valuable pieces of the trade, so if I was a totally rebuilding team, I might prefer the higher 2nd and Roberts. That said, I think Jennings will be more useful and have more value throughout the year, so it's very possible you'd be able to flip him for more to make up the difference anyhow. I'd of course also take Jennings if I was a contending team and needed RB help.

On value alone, the Jennings side should have more value at this very moment.

[Flying Ninja Monkey]

The situation is where I have an abundance of RBs and could use WR depth.... PPR

MY RBS: McCoy, Martin, Lynch, CJ, Jennings, JBell, Todman, Helu (Start 4 Max)

MY WRS: Marshall, Jordy, VJax, Cooper, Burlson

I was thinking about the trade being able to give me a bench WR, but more for the pick to give me a decent shot at a WR.

[Pine Tree]

Looking at your team i'd say Roberts and the higher pick

[Flying Ninja Monkey]

Well... went completely different.

Just traded Jennings, JBell, 2.04, 2.11 for Christine, Sproles (I have McCoy), 1.12, and 2.08.

Perhaps not the best "true value," but in my quest to upgrade my team, Christine and 1.12 probably trade better/easier than Jennings/Bell and 2.04. Sometimes it's other's perceptions that make trades happen. I believe people value Christine pretty high.

[BuckeyeNation]

Well... went completely different.

Just traded Jennings, JBell, 2.04, 2.11 for Christine, Sproles (I have McCoy), 1.12, and 2.08.

Perhaps not the best "true value," but in my quest to upgrade my team, Christine and 1.12 probably trade better/easier than Jennings/Bell and 2.04. Sometimes it's other's perceptions that make trades happen. I believe people value Christine pretty high.

I actually like this trade quite a bit.