David Wilson for Lamar Miller

[tboucher71]

Should I give up on Wilson for Miller straight up?

[DJB]

Yes. Miller has only been held back because of poor coaching. Wilson just isn't very good and the RB situation is very murkey in New York. I actually think A Brown is the one to own in that backfield. So yes make that deal.

[tboucher71]

Thanks I was leaning towards doing it but just needed to hear from someone else that I wasn't crazy for thinking about it.

[DJB]

Miller doesn't have fumbling issues or injury issues either. On top of that his only competition for touches is D Thomas who isn't much of a threat. I see A Brown as a real threat for Wilson.

Happy to help.

[AZK]

Agreed Wilson does have some enticing talent but I see him being very boom or bust and the neck injuries long term are a big concern for his future.

[seahawks506]

I don't think it's wise to throw in the towel on Wilson but you're hardly giving up on him if you're getting Miller back

[meineymoe]

If I could get Miller for Wilson, I would do it in a flash. Of course, I've always been on the Miller side in this debate.

-oo-