Which would you prefer? (Rookies)

[oneluv11223]

Which would you rather have in PPR:

A - Andrew Luck AND Ruben Randall OR Kendall Wright

B - Doug Martin AND Brandon Weeden

C - Justin Blackmon AND Brandon Weeden

16 team league. Start QB, 2 RB, 2WR, 1TE

Currently start:
Eli
DMC and TRich
Julio and Santana Moss
Gronk

[tstafford]

I'd much, much rather have package A.

The only elite player in any of them is Luck, give me the elite guy and a decent prospect every time. Weeden is not going to anything for you other than be a bye week filler.

If for some reason you hate Luck, then package B is the clear choice over C.

[Eight7Seven]

I'd much, much rather have package A.

The only elite player in any of them is Luck, give me the elite guy and a decent prospect every time. Weeden is not going to anything for you other than be a bye week filler.

If for some reason you hate Luck, then package B is the clear choice over C.

1+

[thebeast]

I agree with the post above, A then B. If you take B you should try and trade Martin for a WR that can replace Moss.

[meineymoe]

If you go Martin, I'd rather take Randle, then take a QB in a later round, like Russell Wilson.

-oo-

[tstafford]

If you go Martin, I'd rather take Randle, then take a QB in a later round, like Russell Wilson.

-oo-

Good point.

[rhetoric]

In 16 team league, top QBs are harder to come by...you've got to go with Luck. I don't like Randle or Wright, but Luck by himself outweighs either B or C.

Don't know how you're acquiring these players but if it's via a draft, I'd consider some other WR options that MAY be there like Jeffery or Quick.

[thriftyrocker]

I wouldn't take Luck over Martin in a 16 team if I already had Eli. Unless I had a trade lined up to move Eli.

I would not take Weeden unless he dropped to me in a later round. My choice would be D) Martin and Wright.

[lukeb]

Luck and Randle