Is this trade anywhere close to equal?

[nation31]

Team A: gets 2012 #1 pick, Kenny Britt

Team B: gets James Starks, Antonio Brown

[DynastyFeed]

Yes.

[knuckles50]

Team A wins by a landslide!

[dlf_erich]

I would say no, but maybe the guy giving up Britt is scared of his injury history? I personally wouldn't do it, but Starks is a starting RB and Brown is a likely WR2. I guess it depends where the draft pick is...

[dcr1984]

I would say no, this trade is nowhere near equal.

[harahduh2]

Not even close to equal. I don't think too many people on this site are high on Starks.

[tstafford]

Team A: gets 2012 #1 pick, Kenny Britt

Team B: gets James Starks, Antonio Brown

This trade is awful. It's no where close to equal value.

But who knows, maybe it turns out great for team B. You never know, but I would be irritated if that trade went down in my league. I'd bite my lip and move on, but I'd be annoyed.

[Blackout]

Britt >>>>>>>>>>> Brown

#1 pick >>>>>>>>>>>>> (one hour later when my finger wakes up) >>>>>>>>>>> Starks

Easy to say it's inequal by far.

[lukeb]

I'd be pissed if this trade went down in my league.

[Amoo]

Team A wins by a landslide!

this

[RGKID144]

lol terrible......like antonio alot, but his upside is nowhere near Britt's upside, and Im assuming it's #1 overall? thats Trich, Rg3, or Luck, all of whom couldnt even be put in a discussion with james starks........but hey, if Kenny Britt's career goes down the pooper, its still pretty bad! but at least its not as bad! lol

[nation31]

okay, cause this supposedly went down in my league, and I'm pretty pissed off about it, i just wanted to double check that I wasnt missing something here

[dynastyfever]

the #1 pick, by itself without the top 10 caliber Kenny Britt included, is worth far far more than Antonio Brown and Starks.

Kenny Britt, if you're confident he will return from injury, is easily worth Brown and Starks by himself imo as well.

[DynastyFeed]

Hopefully everyone knew that I was being facetious. That trade is obviously ridiculous.

[DAG]

Team A: gets 2012 #1 pick, Kenny Britt

Team B: gets James Starks, Antonio Brown

This trade is awful. It's no where close to equal value.

But who knows, maybe it turns out great for team B. You never know, but I would be irritated if that trade went down in my league. I'd bite my lip and move on, but I'd be annoyed.

That's why we can veto trades in our league with 5 or more votes against because I suspect there would be alot of those and alot of uproar on the message board.