St. Brown or Jacobs

[ryhan1014]

Feel like I have plenty of RB depth and have been offered the following trade:

I give: Josh Jacobs
I get: Amon Ra St. Brown, 2023 2nd

Would you do the trade?

[FantasyFreak]

Not with your set up. You need the RB depth a lot more than another WR, in start 2 RB. Half PPR, St Brown's value drops a bit, too, compared to full.

[ryhan1014]

Not with your set up. You need the RB depth a lot more than another WR, in start 2 RB. Half PPR, St Brown's value drops a bit, too, compared to full.

Just updated my signature as I have Akers and Edmonds - does that sway your opinion at all?

[Zech13]

I’d keep Jacobs. Not sold on St. Brown though

[Finfansteve]

While I like st. Brown I don’t believe he’s a known enough quantity to trade jacobs for him and would go with jacobs in this overall scenario. The only plus is if that 2023 2nd might be early cause by the jacobs will be another year older and in a strong draft class an early 2nd could be semi valuable. But I’d keep Jacobs personally unless he was willing to give up a better piece than st. Brown and still offer the 2023 second

[Gator Sens]

This is close for me on value but given the format I think you hold Jacobs here. Who knows where Edmonds lands/his role and while Penny and Akers are intriguing, they are also a risk.

[BucBuc]

Not close to me Jacobs easily

[srlarson]

if you want to trade Jacobs...you can get a better WR than st. brown.....

[smmcfarl]

I'd keep Jacobs as well but it's pretty close to me