Which side?

[BabyChark23]

2 QB, 12 team, PPR

Give: Mac Jones, Amon-ra, 22 pick 2.01

Get: Trey Lance

Thoughts?

[Blumpy]

Depends on team need/stage.
Lance higher upside. Mac steady contributor, AMSB balled out and 2.01 in SF will get you a good WR or one of the meh QBs this year

In a vacuum I'd probably take the package over Lance but if your other QBs are like Goff and Bridgewater maybe Lance then

[Gator Sens]

The sky is the limit for Lance but we really don't even know if he will be a starter yet fair or not. I really like Lance but I think he may be a bit like Lamar Jackson in the sense that when he hits, he is fantastic but you have to live with the up and down games. I think the package is safer and nice value but the massive upside is with Lance. Sometimes upside is a misleading thing in dynasty...

[sugbear65]

Mac looks more like a better real life, game manager style QB than a fantasy star. St. Brown has been an awesome story but I’m scared off of his current price tag because I’m not sure a lot of it wasn’t the fact he was basically the only viable option after Hock went down. Did he perfect storm it? I’m not sure but I don’t want to pay a premium to find out. And the 2.01 is what it is.
I’d get Lance. He’s already valued as a top 10 Qb and if you wait for Jimmy to go, and Lance has a few good games out of the gate, you could probably double your investment on a flip pretty easily.