Waddle-Lamb deal? With Poll

[The Showstopper]

Which side would you guys rather have?
Give Lamb
Get Waddle & Mooney?

[StripesOfKC]

Bit of a risk but I'd take Waddle/Mooney

[Gator Sens]

This likely comes down to preference but I would still hold Lamb. Seems like there will be less options in Dallas for targets next year. I think Waddle is great but I am pretty bullish on Lamb long term.

[Mjvb5]

As a waddle owner I'd make this swap to lamb

[Finfansteve]

As a dolphins fan I would stick with Lamb. We don’t know who the new coach is gonna be and what kind of offensive philosophy that coach will bring. We don’t know if tua is the answer and probably won’t for the foreseeable future. Starting over with a new qb won’t be great for waddles near future. Not to mention Miami is one of the worst run franchises in the nfl. And you can say all the same things with Mooney and the Bears. Too many question marks with what you’d be taking on so for those reasons I’d stick with Lamb

[HerbUrban]

I’d stick with Lamb

[Hankybro21]

FWIW in my Team 4 league (10tm SF) I saw Lamb get moved for Waddle + 2022 1.06

[Anteaters]

As a Dolphins fan who owns Waddle and Lamb, I prefer Lamb in a straight up deal.

What would it take added to Waddle? Tough to say, but a 1st if we're talking picks. Probably no later than 1.07. If we're talking players, I'd need a starting-caliber player that I need on my roster added to Waddle.

[FantasyFreak]

Waddle>Lamb

Mooney free

Lamb is massively over rated. He's had the benefit of a bonafide WR1 on the outside, and a top end NFL QB, and racked up his numbers playing slot while having Coop taking coverage away and Dak to throw to him. His numbers aren't even that great. Waddle was a rookie and was a plug n play every week. Spectacular floor, and his explosiveness hasn't even been maximized yet. Mooney put up close to Lamb's numbers on top of that. Their numbers were almost the same, and Mooney did this with lesser QB's than Lamb.

[The.Big.Spank]

Waddle>Lamb

Mooney free

Lamb is massively over rated. He's had the benefit of a bonafide WR1 on the outside, and a top end NFL QB, and racked up his numbers playing slot while having Coop taking coverage away and Dak to throw to him. His numbers aren't even that great. Waddle was a rookie and was a plug n play every week. Spectacular floor, and his explosiveness hasn't even been maximized yet. Mooney put up close to Lamb's numbers on top of that. Their numbers were almost the same, and Mooney did this with lesser QB's than Lamb.

Fair point and voted for the Mooney side as well, but I think Lamb is more a victim of Dak spreading the ball around and not forcing thing than being massively over rated.

[FantasyFreak]

Waddle>Lamb

Mooney free

Lamb is massively over rated. He's had the benefit of a bonafide WR1 on the outside, and a top end NFL QB, and racked up his numbers playing slot while having Coop taking coverage away and Dak to throw to him. His numbers aren't even that great. Waddle was a rookie and was a plug n play every week. Spectacular floor, and his explosiveness hasn't even been maximized yet. Mooney put up close to Lamb's numbers on top of that. Their numbers were almost the same, and Mooney did this with lesser QB's than Lamb.

Fair point and voted for the Mooney side as well, but I think Lamb is more a victim of Dak spreading the ball around and not forcing thing than being massively over rated.

People are putting Ceedee in the the range of top 5 WR's, and until I see something close to that, he's over rated. He's a good WR, but he's not elite, and I don't think he ever will be, either. Coop played hurt or didn't play a lot this year. Gallup only played 9 games this year. He had plenty of opportunity to assert himself as more than a WR2.

[Tripwired]

[/quote]

People are putting Ceedee in the the range of top 5 WR's, and until I see something close to that, he's over rated. He's a good WR, but he's not elite, and I don't think he ever will be, either. Coop played hurt or didn't play a lot this year. Gallup only played 9 games this year. He had plenty of opportunity to assert himself as more than a WR2.
[/quote]

Fantasy Freak, I think you nailed it. Ceedee is really good, but is he worth the top 3Wr ranking I see on most Dynasty rankings? Hmm, it's tough. He hasn't really earned that ranking in my mind. His presumed potential is what has him there. I think Waddle is a ppr machine that has deep threat ability as well. He's really good, similarly to Lamb imo. Adding Mooney makes the difference. In all the rankings I look at Lamb is higher than Waddle, but I don't really think there's that much difference between the two. Waddle out performed Lamb based on his rookie stats and compared to this season, too.

[GB STOCKHOLDERS]

Waddle > Lamb.

[PhillySpecial]

Lamb caught one of Dak’s 43 attempts vs SF. An owner offered me Lamb for Renfrow, Pollard, 2023 1st and two 2022 2nds. I really liked the deal but then I thought that Renfrow might score just as many points as Lamb over the next few seasons and eventually rejected it. I’m still very interested in Lamb by his price currently does not match his production.

[BucBuc]

Bit of a risk but I'd take Waddle/Mooney

x2