Which trade: Tua or Lance at cost?

[Prison_Mike]

Team 3

I have the following trade in my inbox:

Give: Freiermuth + Bourne + ‘23 1st
Get: Lance + Jimmy G + Irv Smith

The owner is lower on Tua, I’m pretty certain I can get a deal done for Tua without giving up my ‘23 1st. I have Tua and Lance ranked fairly close

Something like:

Give: Freiermuth + Bourne + early ‘23 2nd
Get: Tua + ‘22 mid 3rd

Which QB would you prefer at cost?

[Gator Sens]

I think holding Tua and making the other deal is better value.

[Tobin]

I would take Tue because of cost, I wouldn't be getting rid of any 23 1st if don't have to

[halfbaked88]

I think the value is there on the Tua side all day. Tua and Waddle are just beginning their long careers together... you would think. Unless Tua+ gets traded to the Texans for Watson.

If you have Lance and Tua ranked closely then I think for you, take the cost effective trade and save your 1st.

I don't have them ranked closely together. Trey Lance is going to be Jalen Hurts in a San Francisco run first offense. They gave 3 firsts for him. He's not going anywhere. The ceiling there for Lance is insane. And that same rushing gives him a floor.

Jimmy G may just end up being a journeyman like Fitz/Teddy B. You can treat him like getting a 2nd for your 1st. And Bourne to Irv they're roughly the same that just cancels out. (Low on Irv)

[Prison_Mike]

I think the value is there on the Tua side all day. Tua and Waddle are just beginning their long careers together... you would think. Unless Tua+ gets traded to the Texans for Watson.

If you have Lance and Tua ranked closely then I think for you, take the cost effective trade and save your 1st.

I don't have them ranked closely together. Trey Lance is going to be Jalen Hurts in a San Francisco run first offense. They gave 3 firsts for him. He's not going anywhere. The ceiling there for Lance is insane. And that same rushing gives him a floor.

Jimmy G may just end up being a journeyman like Fitz/Teddy B. You can treat him like getting a 2nd for your 1st. And Bourne to Irv they're roughly the same that just cancels out. (Low on Irv)

Thanks for the feedback. I’m low on Irv too btw but think he holds more value than Bourne and think I could flip him to another rebuilding team

[BucBuc]

Tua at cost for me

[BabyChark23]

Lance and Jimmy G deal all day. Jimmy G likely ends up as a starter somewhere else next year. Getting two Starting QB in superflex for that is a great deal.

[frerichs5]

Lance deal for me as well.

[abloom]

Lance and Jimmy g easily here. Even in just a ten teamer.