Antonio Gibson trade opportunities

[Konehead94]

12 team Full PPR 3 WR 2 Flex

Have a couple trades proposed to me for Antonio Gibson, was wondering which one I should take/ if I should at all. The first is Gibson for CMC straight up. The second is Gibson for a late 2022 first, and a 23 first. Any help would be appreciated!

QB: Tannehill, Watson, Bridgewater

RB: Javonte Williams, Antonio Gibson, JK Dobbins, Cam Akers, Khalil Herbert

Wr: Justin Jefferson, Tee Higgins, Brandon Aiyuk, Tyler Boyd, Rashod Bateman, Jamal Agnew

Te: Higbee, Jonnu, Harrison Bryant

[Gator Sens]

Given your young build, I would hold over both offers. If the 2023 1st is realistically early, I think its closer but if both 1sts are mid to late, hold.

[Z$$$]

Hang on to Gibson for now

[jwb32]

Some might argue that CMC is more valuable than Gibson but I am completely out on CMC. I'm holding Gibson easily over both offers.

[murphysxm]

I am piling on, this is a hold for me

[FFFAN]

I sold him for Calvin Ridley, 2022 2ND(mid to late) 2023 1st and 2nd... Hope that helps
Non-ppr

[sugbear65]

I’ll take either trade. I’m not as high on Gibson as most. Two first seems like a good buyout price, and in rebuild I’m not building around RBs anyway, the picks are a much safer bet to retain/increase value. CMac should be able to fetch a high price in the offseason as well, so I would only do that deal to turn around and trade him for profit. You know your league. If that seems unlikely than I’d just take the picks.

[Space Cowboy]

I saw this trade recently

Gibson + 2022 round 1 (mid)

for

CMC + 2023 round 1 (mid to late) and 2023 round 2 (mid to late)

Seemed light to me.

[pmart33]

Without knowing anything about the teams involved or the league format, scoring, etc. I'd imagine that the CMC owner is competing this year and needed to fill a roster hole with Gibson. Not a bad move if that's the case, and Gibson is young enough that he'll be relevant for a few more years. Not having to deal with the headache that is CMC is an added bonus as well.