Wondering if I should pull the trigger

[Remy618]

I'm in a 0.5ppr. I was offered Tom Brady, Travis Kelce and Melvin Gordon for Justin Herbert, Kyle Pitts and K Allen.

I have Cupp, Deebo, Bateman at WR currently. I have JT, Mixon, Edmonds and Mattison at RB.
I just need more opinions on this deal. It seems solid, but I'd lose WR depth. I'm in first place, 5-1 overall

Edit: We start 1QB, 2 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE and 1 flex.

[Ruggenater]

The upgrade from Pitts to Kelce isn’t worth what you’re giving up at QB and WR. This is the Herbert side, and it’s not close at all.

Herbert >>> Brady
Keenan Allen >>> Gordon
Pitts < Kelce

[Remy618]

The upgrade from Pitts to Kelce isn’t worth what you’re giving up at QB and WR. This is the Herbert side, and it’s not close at all.

Herbert >>> Brady
Keenan Allen >>> Gordon
Pitts < Kelce

What's your opinion on it in a redraft for example.

[Ruggenater]

The upgrade from Pitts to Kelce isn’t worth what you’re giving up at QB and WR. This is the Herbert side, and it’s not close at all.

Herbert >>> Brady
Keenan Allen >>> Gordon
Pitts < Kelce

What's your opinion on it in a redraft for example.

This is much more reasonable in redraft. Brady and Herbert is probably an even swap, but I’d have Kelce over Pitts by more than Keenan over Gordon.

[Gator Sens]

If this is redraft, I could see making this move as it helps you for a year. In dynasty, no way you make this move.