Am I too much of a Value Seeker?

[TheBum]

Here is my team currently:

***THIS IS A STANDARD LEAGUE****

QB - Mahomes, Tlaw, Darnold
RB - Kamara, Dobbins, Mixon, Dmont, Darrell Henderson, Gus Edwards, Lat Murray
WR - Chris Godwin, Ceedee, Terry McLaurin, Golladay, Jeudy, Elijah Moore, Jaylen Waddle
TE - Kelce, Kittle, Fant

I was offered the following:

Jamar Chase and a 2022 1

for

Mixon and a projected earlier 2022 1

If I am chasing value I feel it's Chase but I also don't feel this helps me. Thoughts?

[TheBum]

QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, TE, FLEX
***THIS IS A STANDARD LEAGUE****

[never_punts]

Chase side by a mile then figure out a Mixon replacement later, that's too oooooo much value to pass on

Edit**** I misread the picks involved. I think it's much closer than I originally thought, I'd probably hold your side

[Gator Sens]

This puts a lot of stock in Montgomery as your RB3, but I would make this deal long term. This is Mixon's last shot to hold solid value in my opinion and I understand all the camp talk is all over Mixon again this year. I moved him this offseason after holding since his rookie year and don't regret it. I think this is really solid value. The argument could be made that Chase is already more valuable.

This ultimately comes down to if you can live with it if Mixon finally hits more than anything because I do see the value here. I'm guessing this is a 1 QB format also?

Edit: I submitted right one you submitted the format. The potentially earlier 1st is easier to let go of in a 1 QB format. I read the post as the 1st you are moving is supposed to be earlier than the 1st you are getting back or does that mean the pick you move is likely top 3?

[TheBum]

This puts a lot of stock in Montgomery as your RB3, but I would make this deal long term. This is Mixon's last shot to hold solid value in my opinion and I understand all the camp talk is all over Mixon again this year. I moved him this offseason after holding since his rookie year and don't regret it. I think this is really solid value. The argument could be made that Chase is already more valuable.

This ultimately comes down to if you can live with it if Mixon finally hits more than anything because I do see the value here. I'm guessing this is a 1 QB format also?

Edit: I submitted right one you submitted the format. The potentially earlier 1st is easier to let go of in a 1 QB format. I read the post as the 1st you are moving is supposed to be earlier than the 1st you are getting back or does that mean the pick you move is likely top 3?

The 1 I am giving up is likely 1.03-1.05. The one he’s giving me is from the team that won the title.

[Edgy68]

The question comes down to trading Chase for Mixon and would you do it? If the difference between them is less than the dip in 1sts for you, I’d do it.

[Anteaters]

Chase for value.
Chase for win now
Chase for long term
Chase >> Mixon

[murphysxm]

I am in love with Chase and have never been a Mixon guy so this is easy for me

[HughHoney]

Chase side very easily for me

[Jrblaha]

I was on board with chase until I saw you only have to start 2 wrs. Is it PPR?

[Pullo Vision]

Here is my team currently:

***THIS IS A STANDARD LEAGUE****

QB - Mahomes, Tlaw, Darnold
RB - Kamara, Dobbins, Mixon, Dmont, Darrell Henderson, Gus Edwards, Lat Murray
WR - Chris Godwin, Ceedee, Terry McLaurin, Golladay, Jeudy, Elijah Moore, Jaylen Waddle
TE - Kelce, Kittle, Fant

I was offered the following:

Jamar Chase and a 2022 1

for

Mixon and a projected earlier 2022 1

If I am chasing value I feel it's Chase but I also don't feel this helps me. Thoughts?

QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, TE, FLEX
***THIS IS A STANDARD LEAGUE****

Non PPR starting 2 RB, 2 WR and a flex, presuming R/W/T. Start Kittle and Kelce at TE and flex, only start 2 WR between Godwin/McLaurin/Ceedee.

The specifics of this league lead me to pass on giving the more valuable player to build less valuable depth AND give a pick upgrade.

[M-Dub]

Agree with Pullo Vision. In a standard scoring league with shallow starting requirements, Mixon > Chase. The fact that you’d also be giving up the better pick makes it an easier pass.

[SHIZZLE]

Chase side for me......Mixon never was and never will be a stud, he's above average in a good situation, but thats it. The offense seems ready to let burrow throw a ton. I like Chase upside way more than mixon. Plus you can flip one or two of your WR's to grab a stud RB since you have many greta starting WR's. I would easily go with the Chase side.