TE Premium: Andrews for Carson/Diontae (updated)?

[mzkp54]

Team 2 in sig. SF, PPR and 1.5 TE premium.

Would you trade Mark Andrews and a ‘23 2nd for Chris Carson and Deebo Samuel?

EDIT: Rejected and he countered with just Andrews for the pair.

EDIT 2: Newest offer is Andrews/'23 3rd for Carson/Diontae

[Gator Sens]

With the slight premium I would lean holding Andrews despite the RB help. I think with injuries and age, this is the last year for Carson as a helpful contributor.

[never_punts]

I don't care for the pieces you are getting back. A young TE who has shown tremendous upside should be worth more in that format.

[mzkp54]

He countered without the 2nd. Any more appealing?

Other consideration is that it is a contract league and all 3 players are on 1 year contracts so will have to pay to keep them after this year.

[sloth8u]

Fair offer, but not a dynasty league trade that I would make. I expect penny to take over eventually and Deebo to be inconsistent. My feeling.... If your moving Andrews, there's got to be a better deal out there.

[murphysxm]

This can not be the best package you can get for Andrews in a format that leans even slightly to a TE's advantage.

[mzkp54]

This can not be the best package you can get for Andrews in a format that leans even slightly to a TE's advantage.

Haha well the last offer I got for him was Harrison Bryant and Philip Lindsay so you’d be surprised

[sloth8u]

He countered without the 2nd. Any more appealing?

Other consideration is that it is a contract league and all 3 players are on 1 year contracts so will have to pay to keep them after this year.

If you don't plan on resigning Andrews...I think the package gives you a better chance for 1 yr, simply by adding depth for the yr. If the plan is/was to bring him back for a few yrs...I'd stick to the plan. Even if pitts hits, you can play both. I did that an awful lot with gronk/graham, kelce/ertz, and hoping to do so with hock/fant.

[jwb32]

I would pass. I like Deebo but his injury history scares me. And the end is near for Carson.

[mzkp54]

Sorry one more- what do we think if he swapped in Diontae Johnson for Deebo?

[HughHoney]

DJ/Carson comfortably for me.

[never_punts]

Sorry one more- what do we think if he swapped in Diontae Johnson for Deebo?

Andrews/'23 3rd for Carson/Diontae - this is much more fair and an offer that would get me very interested. I'd probably take that.

[Needalife]

I would take Carson/Diontae but not the Deebo one. Also, I would try and grab Hurst on the cheap in case Pitts gets injured. Your team is too good not to have that insurance because losing Andrews leaves you thin at TE. Logan Thomas could repeat but he also has a new QB which adds uncertainty. Roster is too strong not to tie up those loose ends.