AJB, is this the day?

[IR1]

What are starting requirements? You have the depth to move AJ if 2 rb.

[Shoreline Steamers]

I'd hold Brown.

Two aging assets, although studs in their prime, seems like a downgrade to me. Pass.

[PhillySpecial]

I would not make the trade as Kamara and Evans have no value growth potential. I agree with never_punts on two depreciating assets. AJB could still appreciate to the 1.01 (long shot) overall while Kamara and Evans have peaked and could drop substantially in 2-3 years.

[Paul717]

I'd probably take such a deal for AJB but I'll admit by bias and love for Kamara, plus my RB room is very thin (currently, and typically).

For the OP it really comes down to making a run this year. I think Kamara becomes a starter on that team and the WR room is still packed. Love AJB too, and this is a tough pill to swallow; but I'd pull the trigger.

P.S. - No one in my league would ever offer such a package. For example the Evans owner would probably scoff at adding anything to Evans to get AJB. This is a nice starting offer. Any chance he'd add a small cherry on top? Maybe he says "heck no"...and that might be your sign to walk away.

[SStory93]

I'd probably take such a deal for AJB but I'll admit by bias and love for Kamara, plus my RB room is very thin (currently, and typically).

For the OP it really comes down to making a run this year. I think Kamara becomes a starter on that team and the WR room is still packed. Love AJB too, and this is a tough pill to swallow; but I'd pull the trigger.

P.S. - No one in my league would ever offer such a package. For example the Evans owner would probably scoff at adding anything to Evans to get AJB. This is a nice starting offer. Any chance he'd add a small cherry on top? Maybe he says "heck no"...and that might be your sign to walk away.

Appreciate all the input!

I walked away, not big on letting trades sit for an hour or more when I acknowledge they are there. I am personally in the camp of "live or die" with AJB. He my favorite player to have in all dynasty and is arguably WR1 in dynasty football. From jump street I thought the offer was good if given for any of my other two WRS (DK, JJ) I am very likely to take it. However, to snag AJ Brown I would need a player like Mahomes back. That just how much I like to have him on my team. I in fact swapped places with the person in 1.10 in the startup with my 1.01 just to assure I could grab AJB. It wasn't logical but it has resulted in me getting the sexiest lineup of WRs I could ask for, so to me that is a "W". If the person that gave me the offer AJB added Kittle to the trade I might've pulled the trigger since then I would be assured a competing team. He understandably wouldn't do for multiple reason, but the main one is he just got Kittle from me for A. Jones, Big Ben, and Rondale Moore and is a huge Kittle fan.

[Dynastydumpsterfire]

Got get kamara with your 1st and seconds for 2022 and 2023 and keep AJ Brown.

[The.Big.Spank]

I think its fair to devalue Kamara a bit since Brees retired. I think AJ is actually overvalued a bit. 1000 yards and 10 TDs a year is nice, but I dont see what everybody is going ga-ga over. I think we all got spoiled for a few years with Calvin, AJ and Julio just crushing it at a Hall of Fame pace, but since then receivers like Diggs, Brown, have rotating with those 1000/10Td numbers on various years.

[j4pac]

Even when Kamara’s rushing ability drops off he’ll still be an elite receiver until he retires. Kamara is one of the few RBs that I can say that I’d be surprised if he wasn’t fantasy relevant well into his 30s. His receiving ability makes him sustainable. I’m going that route pretty easily, though I do like Brown. Even without Evans, the Kamara side wins.