Counter trade offer?

[SStory93]

Thank you for my previous post about Ridley trade the man has countered and I do say I want to here your input once again.

Team A: Calvin Ridley and Shenault
Team B: DK Metcalf and Mooney

What side and why? Thanks for all the input

[WP3]

I’d lean Ridley side. Shenault just has more upside than Mooney. I think Ridley has a top 5 season. He and metcalf have as solid of prospects going forward as anybody.

[BabyChark23]

I’d take Team A. I think the difference in Shenault and Mooney is enough to make up for the difference in DK and Ridley.

[Gator Sens]

I still lean Ridley here as well based on all factors. His name may not be as valuable, but Ridley out produced Metcalf.

[SStory93]

Interesting! This is one of those ones I’m a bit surprised by the responses.

[vixen]

I honestly cannot decide.. I would probably take Ridley side.. but ask me in an hour and I would probably have a different answer

[never_punts]

It's close and I like DK a lotttt but I'd still want the Ridley side with shenault

[atlmoneyman]

Leaning DK side.

[BucBuc]

Ridley side cause of Shenault

[tsarpepe]

Shenault and Mooney are both unknowns, with hopes and doubts around them both. I don't think you can make a case that there's a substantial difference between them that closes the gap between the two studs. DK side for me.

[meineymoe]

Shenault and Mooney are both unknowns, with hopes and doubts around them both. I don't think you can make a case that there's a substantial difference between them that closes the gap between the two studs. DK side for me.

This for me. I am high on both Mooney and Shenault, and would consider moving Shenault for Mooney in the slight upgrade from Ridley to Metcalf, my wr1.

-oo-

[CGW]

I slightly lean DK side, but can see the argument either way. Personal preference here.

In a 10tm league or less i'd go with DK. In a league where depth was important id probably go Ridley and Shenault as I like Shenault over Mooney.