DJM for Gibson?

[never_punts]

Team #1 in sig. Would you move DJM straight up for Antonio Gibson to get better at RB? If not, what would you want added to either side?

[Gator Sens]

Value is pretty close straight up and comes down to preference and build. I would not add to either side. Gibson looks to help your build more on paper.

[PR0v3]

I would need something added to DJM for my Gibson, probably a first round pick, so yes I would move him straight up.

DJM is a nice young player but he hasn't separated himself from the 30 other WRs that produce in that WR15-45 range.

Gibson, with his athleticism and RB1 rookie season, is about as valuable an asset as there is in dynasty.

[never_punts]

Valuation of both of these players seems to be all over the place. I know Gibson is the "riskier" of the two, but his ceiling is sky high given his tools and the position he plays. I could've easily gotten Gibson+ for DJM a few short months ago, and now it's expected that the DJM owner should add to get Gibson. I'm really considering pulling the trigger on DJM+ to get Gibson and then moving Monty, but it's looking like I'll have to add something not insignificant to DJM to get the deal done.

[Z$$$]

I’d value them close to straight up. I can see both owners wanting a little on top to trade. Gibson helps your team more IMO.

[bennythedog93]

I agree with everyone here. The value is pretty straight up but as often happens, RBs command more. In this case though, a 1st would be too much. Maybe a ‘22 2nd????

[Needalife]

Gibson side by a late 1st or very early 2nd.

[never_punts]

I appreciate all of your comments. Maybe I'm too high on DJM. I really hate the Panthers went Darnold and didn't pull the trigger on Fields. I sent the deal straight up to see what he may counter.

[RoyalDynasty]

Yes, Gibson over DJM and better for your team

[dblj1199]

DJM and Gibson both have question marks with them. DJM has produced all three years with uneven qb play, what will Darnold be? Upgrade? More of the same? Do the Panthers sign him long term or is he a FA after his 5th year option plays out. Gibson didn't play a featured role in college and had uneven stats last season. He has Fitz, who will they have a qb long term? They helped out the o-line and added help with Samuel, so how does S Turner use him in a new offense? Too me DJM is more of a proven asset here. What do you have for draft capital in this seasons draft?

[never_punts]

DJM and Gibson both have question marks with them. DJM has produced all three years with uneven qb play, what will Darnold be? Upgrade? More of the same? Do the Panthers sign him long term or is he a FA after his 5th year option plays out. Gibson didn't play a featured role in college and had uneven stats last season. He has Fitz, who will they have a qb long term? They helped out the o-line and added help with Samuel, so how does S Turner use him in a new offense? Too me DJM is more of a proven asset here. What do you have for draft capital in this seasons draft?

In the 2021 draft I only had a 4th and a 5th. I traded away my early picks last year for essentially a combination of Kittle, JuJu, Robert Woods
I took some random fliers with my picks this year

In the 2022 draft, I have two firsts (one projected mid and one projected late) & one 2nd (late)