AJB+ vs Etienne+Mclaurin

[SkinZ187]

10 team ppr, MUST start 3 RB, 4 WR, 2 TE league.



AJ Brown + Mike Davis + 2022 2nd + Bryan Edwards

vs

Mclaurin + Etienne

how far off is this in value?

important note ... both sides will be viewing this thread and we might make the deal if the consensus feels this is a pretty even deal.

[Gator Sens]

Value is pretty close overall with the potential of Etienne. Brown is the best piece, but the secondary piece/pieces are on the Etienne side. Preference, but I prefer Brown + solely because of Brown.

[OhSnapItsAnt]

AJB>Terry slightly
And
ETN> Mike Davis,2nd, Edwards.

Only way I can see moving on from AJB is if you really believe in Etienne.

Team need would help me decide this better.

[SkinZ187]

to add some context to the situation, the team receiving AJB is in a rebuild and a very very young team... the team getting etienne / mclaurin side is a compete now team that also owns James Robinson.

AJB being a couple years younger than Mclaurin weighs into this.

Mike Davis would just be flipped to another team netting the rebuilding team some more draft capital.

[Bennyblanco22]

Despite the AJB side getting Mike Davis, I think that side is the one I'd prefer but not by a lot. Mike Davis should be a really solid RB that a contender should easily pay a future first for (if he produces consistently like I think, and because you must start 3rbs) so I in my mind I'd be looking at it like Ajb and a first, second, and a decent prospect in Edwards. I can see the contending team wanting Etienne because of Robinson, but I don't think the deal will net you more ppg, because I don't see Etienne having a large enough role consistently to outscore Davis in 2021, and starting Jrob and Etienne would probably be a low ceiling play. Jax rushed the fewest times in the league if I remember correctly. Of course they're due for a decent amount of positive regression but who knows. Ramblin, but just some thoughts on the trade.