Tannehill sell now?

[halfbaked88]

I am worried about Tannehill. The wideouts the Titans took in the 4th round and beyond do not inspire confidence, nor does Josh Reynolds or Firkser ...

He just had a career high 40 TD season (33 passing/7 rushing) that just screams regression.

What rookie or current QBs would you target in trade to move R. Tannehill?

My league discounts passing TDs from 6 to 4 pts so rushing QBs are more valuable.

[Gator Sens]

In a 16 team SF format, I would be looking at the top QBs outside of Lawrence in this class. Fields, Wilson or Lance. Given the large team format, I feel Tannehill is very valuable. I certainly would not sell low.

[Indyfan1985]

I would sell him. I fully believe he will regress this year with losing OC Arthur Smith who helped resurrect his career along with losing both Corey Davis and Jonnu Smith and not replacing either player.

[halfbaked88]

Problem is I don't know to sell him for. I have the top 4 rookie QBs ahead of him, but I really on want Trey Lance. Lawrence is outta my price range. And Zach Wilson and Justin Fields I value more than Tannehill, but not by much. They carry a fair amount of risk because the Jets and Bears are crappy/average at best football teams. At least the Titans can move the ball with Henry and he 'could' still score 30+TDs between high pointing AJ Brown and running the dang ball in himself.

I am hoping to contend passed the first round of the playoffs this year; unlike last year. [There are tiered cash prizes to division winners and playoff wins.]

I have the same problem with Baker Mayfield and Tua - I value them higher, but again, not by much. Tua's unproven. I might try Baker Mayfield though. It's looking like the Browns are the favorites in the NFC North and he's been "good," almost great, with room to improve.

Stafford would be nice, but I would have to overpay the owner loves him.

I think I'm going to offer Tannehill while we're drafting. This is actually a 32 team 2 copy league. Once the first copy of Trey Lance goes I'll offer him for the next pick...

Or is Tannehill + my 22' 1st a lowball offer for Baker Mayfield?

Any thoughts appreciated

[StripesOfKC]

I would really just prefer to hold

Was told to sell all last offseason and that regression was coming and the Titans were a fluke and caught lightning in a bottle

He just went out and did it again. You aren't going to get fair value back (and no Tanny+1st for Baker is not fair value)

[KAT]

I had Tannehill, Baker, Lamar, and trey lance. I traded Baker and tannehill for Dak and Jordan love.

I love Dak. But It really hurt trading Tannehill. Dude has been a monster for the last 2 years.

[halfbaked88]

Sigh. Ok. He has been a solid option at QB. Looking back at his game log in my league the dude doesn't score less than 15 pts almost ever, many 20pters, a couple 30 pt games. The other copy of Tannehill was traded for the 1.15 (i.e. the 1.07) that's probably good for Zach Wilson. I don't think I'd do that deal.

I think Tannehill executes in a good system. He's an average QB to me i.e. not gonna win games alone, but not going to lose you many either.

Mike Vrabel is a good coach... can we trust the Titans organization. Not replacing Corey Davis and Jonnu adequately?? I just don't know. If anything were the happen to Henry that whole offense is dead.

I think I have to hold here... based on his floor. I'm just bummed the multiple 2, 3, 4 TD games are probably not going to be there this year like they were in 2020. The ceiling just feels way lower. That 33 passing TDs is looking more like 25 at best.

The limited upside is just an unfortunate outcome of free agency & the draft I guess. Hopefully he can retain performance with AJ Brown and maybe increase his rushing yds and TDs to make up for it.

[CGW]

He's not going to fetch what he's worth. He's always going to be undervalued like Kirk Cousins, except hes got more rushing upside.

He's got the most dominant rusher in the game keeping defenses on the line. He's got one of the best WR in football to throw to. I'm not all that worried about losing Davis and Smith.