Reasonable PPR Dynasty offer?

[Buckhill Bombers]

Wanted to get some opinions.

Give: Evans and Kittle
Get: Metcalf and 1.5

12 team PPR dynasty, we start 1qb, 2rb, 3wr, 1te, 1 flex.

[Jigga94]

Kittle more or less is on par with DK. I think Evans is more valuable than 1.05 but could see the argument either way

[tsarpepe]

Hard to judge without knowing your team. Argument could be made for either side depending on team needs.

[Gator Sens]

Very close overall on the surface. The Evans side has less bust rate but I can see the Metcalf side being more enticing this time of year. I also prefer Metcalf to Evans at this point. This comes down to build and if you want to gamble on a pick.

[punintended]

i like the Evans side...if it was Superflex id go DK side

[Buckhill Bombers]

Here is my current roster. Would you prefer roster as is or prefer Matcalf and the pick?
Watson, Ryan, Tannehill
Gibson, Sanders, Ron Jones, Mostert, Vaughn
Evans, Cooper, Diontae Johnson, Jeudy, Crowder, Preston Williams, Duvernay, A. Miller
Kelce, Kittle, Ebron, Howard

[dblj1199]

Here is my current roster. Would you prefer roster as is or prefer Matcalf and the pick?
Watson, Ryan, Tannehill
Gibson, Sanders, Ron Jones, Mostert, Vaughn
Evans, Cooper, Diontae Johnson, Jeudy, Crowder, Preston Williams, Duvernay, A. Miller
Kelce, Kittle, Ebron, Howard

Is this a te premium or your just starting Kittle as a best option? I think that the deal is pretty even overall. I guess it comes down to if your competing this year I may hold. If you think with the Watson situation hurting your chances I'm taking the young stud and the pick.

[Buckhill Bombers]

Its not TE premium I just start both TEs because Kittle is my best flex option

[ProfPoobah]

If you have Kelce at TE, then for a dynasty league with no TE premium I prefer Metcalf and the pick