Aiyuk/Sermon vs Devonta Smith

[MTerry00]

Was just offered Aiyuk and Sermon for Smith. Don't really know what to expect out of either the Eagles or 49ers offenses this year but I suspect Smith will lead the eagles in targets at least. While Aiyuk will be the 2nd option at best and Sermon will be splitting time.



Thoughts?

[Gator Sens]

I think the value is there to make this deal and Aiyuk showed very well last year, but I would hold and see how Smith pans out. I'm very high on Smith though, so...

[Mtt33]

Prefer aiyuk to smith slightly so this is a free sermon in my eyes.

[Jigga94]

Aiyuk side

[CGW]

Interesting, I expected this to be overwhelming for Aiyuk. Hes shown in the NFL what we hope Smith can be and he's a better size for an alpha WR.

[StripesOfKC]

Aiyuk over Smith and not close to me so Sermon is just icing on the cake

[Shoreline Steamers]

Preach Sermon!

You get an attractive WR in Aiyuk who played well last year. And you don't have to hope that Smith's game translates to the pro's. Easy accept for me.

[Weavere]

Aiyuk easy!

[Zhoward88]

I have Aiyuk and wouldn’t even trade him straight up for smith. I’m hesitant that smith even plays the full season. Hoping he does but it’s not super likely his body holds up. A lot of time normal size rookies don’t even last. Sermon is free here and then some. Aiyuk please.

[mild]

Slam dunk. Aiyuk even without Sermon.

[M-Dub]

Piling on for Aiyuk + a free Sermon. Nice cash-in on rookie fever.

[KING]

Sermon truther here. Easy accept for me

[jwb32]

This is how you take advantage of rookie fever. Aiyuk for Smith is an tougher call. But getting a free Sermon makes this a slam dunk.