ARob v Javonte Williams

[Adam_172]

Team in Sig 3.

Could do with RB help but am I underselling ARob?

[Adam_172]

Javonte just went at 1.10 in the rookie draft.

[BradysBunch]

I like where Williams landed ( enough for me to consider him as the same tier as Harris and ETN ), I think by mid season he is the back to have in DEN. I would take Williams over AROB here.

[Jigga94]

Give me Williams. He looks good enough to be an RB2, plays at the much more scarce position and is much younger. Oh and he's not stuck in Chicago

[Gator Sens]

I would need something solid up top of Williams. Robinson is a too 10 producing WR multiple years now. I understand how pricey RBs are and rookies are exciting but this is a very risky deal selling a well established and point scorer straight up.

[Adam_172]

Thanks guys, I must admit, I thought i'd see a 80% + split in ARob's favor.

Do you think i'm trying to push too much if I ask him to add a 2022 2nd?

So, ARob for Javonte + 2022 2nd

[Jigga94]

Thanks guys, I must admit, I thought i'd see a 80% + split in ARob's favor.

Do you think i'm trying to push too much if I ask him to add a 2022 2nd?

So, ARob for Javonte + 2022 2nd

If he came to you, that's more than fair

[Anteaters]

I love ARob and think he is criminally undervalued. But dang, I think Javonte is the real deal and he landed in a great spot. It's tearing me apart, but I chose Javonte. But I agree with Gator that something else should come back on top of Javonte. A 2022 2nd (hopefully high) looks good.

[Zhoward88]

This is easily Williams. Robinsons age and WR being so easy to replace for production allows Williams the answer here. 35th overall in the draft on a team that just moved off a RB and has another injury prone back in front of him. Yep, JW all day everyday here. Might not get anything close to what you want for robinson this time next year.

[OhSnapItsAnt]

I would need something solid up top of Williams. Robinson is a too 10 producing WR multiple years now. I understand how pricey RBs are and rookies are exciting but this is a very risky deal selling a well established and point scorer straight up.

Completely agree with this..
I remember thinking Rashaad Penny and Darrel Henderson landed in great spots....

You’re trading a proven STUD for an unproven rookie..you’re taking the risk. i think it’s extreme to say Williams>Allen Robinson when we have no idea how he’s going to pan out. You’re taking a huge risk with your team.
I’d feel way more comfortable trying to get a 2nd added if you can.
But dont get me wrong, I love Javonte and I have him ranked as my #2 rookie RB. So I wouldn’t be completely mad if you did this straight up. But to be realistic ARob>javonte

Btw in a team not in my sig. I sold ARob and 2.5 for CEH, Viska, so I do think it’s a good time to sell him.

[punintended]

Zero chance I trade my arob for 1.10.

With your team and lack of WR depth even less of a chance I would do that. He’s criminally underrated and no Dalton and Fields are significantly better than anyone he’s played with.

Rookie fever is alive and well.

[Madcity_matt]

Thanks guys, I must admit, I thought i'd see a 80% + split in ARob's favor.

Do you think i'm trying to push too much if I ask him to add a 2022 2nd?

So, ARob for Javonte + 2022 2nd

absolutely try for it

[Adam_172]

Thanks guys, love the comments. I'm gonna counter with the 2nd added.