Keenan Allen For Aiyuk

[95dent]

0.5 PPR how far apart are they trade wise, what needs adding where?

No particular team need from either side

[Jigga94]

Allen side probably needs a late 1st added due to age

[sloth8u]

Basically even value right now. I believe allen gets the slight edge in adp and rankings, but as mentioned, age is with aiyuk. If I'm contending.... I want the sure thing but would not add much to get allen. Aiyuk is the guy to gamble on if your a few yrs away. Wouldn't add much to acquire him either. Really even value here. Proven vs prospect....take your pick

[krtbuckeye]

I don’t think they’re far apart at all, but could see adding to either side depending on build/preference. As Sloth said, if contending, I could see adding to Aiyuk to get Allen. If rebuilding, I could see adding to Allen to get years back with Aiyuk.

[Gator Sens]

I can see Aiyuk having a touch more value due to age and Allen always being underrated. A 2nd on top of Allen may get it done, but it should not be necessary.

[Nightmares]

Basically even value right now. I believe allen gets the slight edge in adp and rankings, but as mentioned, age is with aiyuk. If I'm contending.... I want the sure thing but would not add much to get allen. Aiyuk is the guy to gamble on if your a few yrs away. Wouldn't add much to acquire him either. Really even value here. Proven vs prospect....take your pick

This is where I am at on their value and have shares of both.

[jwb32]

There is little demand for Keenan at current perceived value. This is Aiyuk side by at least a very early 2nd....most likely a late 1st. If you buy Keenan right now, you know you'll never recoup your investment. Aiyuk could easily net you a solid profit as early as this season.

[sloth8u]

There is little demand for Keenan at current perceived value. This is Aiyuk side by at least a very early 2nd....most likely a late 1st. If you buy Keenan right now, you know you'll never recoup your investment. Aiyuk could easily net you a solid profit as early as this season.

This works both ways and allen may be the better value according to perception. Perception has both somewhere in the 10-15 range. You may be able to buy allen for that...but not many aiyuk owners would sell for that. I was quoted 1.5 a couple days ago.

I like aiyuk and would draft him before allen, but that could be said comparing similar players from adp1-adp200. I get personal preference and going after your guy...but I personally would not give much to go either way and I think you'd be hard pressed to find an allen owner to fully commit and add a top 15 to get aiyuk.

[tsarpepe]

I'd want a 2nd on top of Aiyuk to move Allen.

[jwb32]

There is little demand for Keenan at current perceived value. This is Aiyuk side by at least a very early 2nd....most likely a late 1st. If you buy Keenan right now, you know you'll never recoup your investment. Aiyuk could easily net you a solid profit as early as this season.

This works both ways and allen may be the better value according to perception. Perception has both somewhere in the 10-15 range. You may be able to buy allen for that...but not many aiyuk owners would sell for that. I was quoted 1.5 a couple days ago.

I like aiyuk and would draft him before allen, but that could be said comparing similar players from adp1-adp200. I get personal preference and going after your guy...but I personally would not give much to go either way and I think you'd be hard pressed to find an allen owner to fully commit and add a top 15 to get aiyuk.

Allen is a great buy for a contender. But you better be a very strong contender because you ain't getting your money back.