Saquon’s value

[nobodybeatstheviz]

12-team, ppr devy league

What can I reasonably expect to get in return for Saquon Barkley?

I’ve been offered Etienne/Ja’Marr Chase/Tyler Johnson/4.07 (this is a first round devy pick) for Barkley/JuJu

My team seems like it is in a constant rebuild and my roster is as follows:

QB - Murray, Dak, Ryan, Taysom Hill
RB - Barkley, Edmunds, Swift, Cohen, Snell, White, DWilliams
WR - Ridley, JuJu, CDavis, Landry, Meyers, Miller, Pittman, Riggs, Slayton
TE - Waller, Jonnu, Jarwin

Would you make this trade or hold out for more?

Thank you in advance.

[Gator Sens]

Barkley is worth multiple 1sts. I'm high on Chase but he and Etienne are unknowns. This deal would be a huge gamble and holding Barkley is the way to go here. Asking JuJu on top seems like a major reach too.

[M-Dub]

What do you mean by the 4.07 being a first round devy pick? Are you not allowed to select devy players in the first three rounds of your draft?

Regardless, there’s no way you should be adding JuJu in this deal. You could probably make a case for trading Barkley alone for that package in a rebuild, but JuJu is no mere throw-in.

[halfbaked88]

He just went for Justin Jefferson, Reagor and 2.09 on my league.

[Mtt33]

I thought that was a decent offer (if that’s a 1st round devy) until I saw you’re adding juju. Easy pass for me. Even without juju, I think I’d want something a little better than Johnson.

[nobodybeatstheviz]

Thanks for the responses everyone.

Our league does the first three rounds of the draft in May and those rounds are for rookies and veteran free agents. The last three rounds are done in August and those are the Devy picks. So, round four is the first round of the Devy draft.

[jwb32]

That team isn’t competing with or without Barkley. I’d counter with Corey Davis in place of JuJu. Unless you have some premium rookie picks, you need to make some bold moves or you’ll be stuck in limbo for the foreseeable future. Getting the 1.02 and 1.03 for Barkley is a solid return.

[MyTeam]

He was traded for the 1.03, 1.11 and next year second in a SF I am in.

[Jigga94]

He just went for Justin Jefferson, Reagor and 2.09 on my league.

I like that deal. Stud for stud.

I don't like OPs deal. 2 great prospects but that's not a lot for Saquon. Take JuJu out and maybe I'd consider it more

OP, if you are always in rebuild, I don't like the idea of trading studs away when they aren't that old. Saquon should net you a huge overpay where you don't need to ask if it's a good deal. Maybe picks are overvalued in your league and you can trade yours for proven players?

[tsarpepe]

He was traded for the 1.03, 1.11 and next year second in a SF I am in.

That's also pretty light for Quads.

[MyTeam]

He was traded for the 1.03, 1.11 and next year second in a SF I am in.

That's also pretty light for Quads.

Everyone else in the league thought so too. Wish I would have known that was the price and I would have sent it.

[krtbuckeye]

That’s a pretty poor offer for Saquon AND JuJu, IMO. I could possibly see an argument for moving Saquon alone for this in a rebuild, but a hard pass on the original offer.

[Shoreline Steamers]

I'm not averse to trading Saquon, but agree with the others that this isn't the deal you want to make.

If it were me, I probably wouldn't be looking to deal him right now anyway. Coming off the injury, people are likely looking for/expecting some sort of discount. I'd just hold until he's back on the field looking good, then sell him if you want to. I believe his value will be increasing in the next few months.

[Adam_172]

Hard hard pass for me