Trade away Shenault+1.12(2021)+1st(2020) and get Diggs?

[mcGoldyyy]

In a 16-Team HPPR 1QB Dynasty:

Would you Trade away Shenault+1.12(2021)+1st(2022) for Diggs ?

(+get 2.14 and give away 3.12 2021 pickswap)


Thanks a lot in advance for your opinions!

[Gator Sens]

This depends a bit on build and starting requirements since depth is so important in a 16 team league. On the surface, the price is fair for Diggs, but if you are short on depth or not a contender, I would probably hold hard on league size.

[BradysBunch]

I initial thought is no. A lot to give up in a 16 team league. I dont know your roster/starting req so I could see someone doing this...but again, a lot of capital

[mcGoldyyy]

The league is kind of a dynasty-keeper-contract-league: here are my pactive on roster players:
QB: Murray
RB: Swift/Dobbins/J.Robinson/Singeltary
WR:Michael Thomas/Ceedee Lamb/Antonio Gandy-Golden/Jalen Hurd
TE: Engram

could keep: Amendola/DeMarcus Robinson/Pollard/Gus Edwards/and more non-relevant players

Have to start: 1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 3WRT

[krtbuckeye]

Despite being a 16 team, I think this team is in a great spot contention-wise and you have a bit of depth. You have 3 solid RBs and this deal would improve your WR group. I like Diggs here.

[MyTeam]

The league is kind of a dynasty-keeper-contract-league: here are my pactive on roster players:
QB: Murray
RB: Swift/Dobbins/J.Robinson/Singeltary
WR:Michael Thomas/Ceedee Lamb/Antonio Gandy-Golden/Jalen Hurd
TE: Engram

could keep: Amendola/DeMarcus Robinson/Pollard/Gus Edwards/and more non-relevant players

Have to start: 1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 3WRT

I don't think you have the depth to make the trade. Overall, that looks like a solid team but right now, you can't fill the starting requirements with guys I would want to start. So I would hold the picks and add some more depth behind MT and Lamb.

[Edgy68]

The league is kind of a dynasty-keeper-contract-league: here are my pactive on roster players:
QB: Murray
RB: Swift/Dobbins/J.Robinson/Singeltary
WR:Michael Thomas/Ceedee Lamb/Antonio Gandy-Golden/Jalen Hurd
TE: Engram

could keep: Amendola/DeMarcus Robinson/Pollard/Gus Edwards/and more non-relevant players

Have to start: 1QB 2RB 3WR 1TE 3WRT

I don't think you have the depth to make the trade. Overall, that looks like a solid team but right now, you can't fill the starting requirements with guys I would want to start. So I would hold the picks and add some more depth behind MT and Lamb.

I think the price is fine, but the 3 flex spots lends a little weight to this take. You’re in a nice spot right now. If you take this deal, one or two injuries sinks you and you’d have little to no draft capital left to fix it.

[mcGoldyyy]

Thanks a lot guys! Guess I don’t accept bc of your Good arguments regarding depth

Hope I can get a good WR at 1.12 for years and maybe a solid one at the end of the second