Difference between Henry and Dobbins

[Disaman74]

What’s the difference in value between DHenry and Dobbins? I have last 1st and 3rd in this years draft and all the players in my signature. Not sure the owner is even willing to part with Henry, but if he is I wanted to know thoughts on what I would need to add to Dobbins and if it was worth it given my build? Thanks

[Blumpy]

If I'm the Dobbins owner, I'd do the trade only if I'm contending but even then I wouldn't add due to age difference.

If I'm the Henry owner, Im not adding. So I guess I wouldn't add either way unless it's like a 3rd or something.

Henry probably has 1-2 years left at peak at most. Dobbins looks good but who knows what Ravens do with their RBs

[gogobradyarm]

I want Dobbins over Henry.

[Disaman74]

Finished in 2nd this year, but was really planning to contend starting next year

[Gator Sens]

Dobbins is the much better long term asset, but I think Henry has one more elite year. Pretty even overall currently depending on goals for an owner this year.

[joeday]

I think Henry has 2 years left, but I don't own him in PPR anywhere so I could understand not wanting to invest in him. I also don't know how much I like Dobbins in PPR (the Ravens don't throw to their RBs too often). I am seeing people in other threads talking about adding a 2 with Dobbins to get Kamara, which may be the better choice.

[Edgy68]

I realize it’s .5 PPR, but since you finished 2nd, I would hold. You have 3 solid young RBs in Swift, Akers, and Dobbins, all who spent the last half of the year growing into lead roles. Dobbins didn’t start getting the majority of carries until later in the year. When he did, he showed what he is capable of. The bump you get by adding Henry is more likely to be slight than not over a full season of Dobbins.
For what it’s worth, I would be looking to trade Henry for Dobbins, not the other way around.

[esloan35]

Keep Dobbins IMO.

[MyTeam]

I'd take Dobbins over Henry right now in a start up.

[jwb32]

Henry has hit the hot potato age. You are playing with fire here. Tread carefully.

[Disaman74]

Thanks all... keeping dobbins and continuing my build based on feedback