Kamara for Dobbins+

[kilgorextrout]

This is probably a no brainer, but would love some feedback. Juggernaut in the league who trades and reloads well to win constantly offered this :

His Kamara/nobody LB
My Dobbins/2.03

Team linked at bottom, QB/2RB/3WR/TE/Flex/SF

[Gator Sens]

Dobbins looks like a great asset, but this is Kamara on value.

[tsarpepe]

Kamara easily

[Badgersfan222]

Thats a pretty good price. I'd do that for sure.

[MyTeam]

Value says Kamara but I don't invest in 26 year old RBs

[kilgorextrout]

Value says Kamara but I don't invest in 26 year old RBs

This has been my reservation. I don’t think Kamara makes me an immediate contender against his and a few other stacked teams.

[joeday]

Value says Kamara but I don't invest in 26 year old RBs

This has been my reservation. I don’t think Kamara makes me an immediate contender against his and a few other stacked teams.

I think the value (especially the flip value) of Kamara is worth more than JKD and 2.3

Also, I don't think the cliff of RBs is as young as 26, especially ones that don't take a ton of hits.

[MyTeam]

Value says Kamara but I don't invest in 26 year old RBs

This has been my reservation. I don’t think Kamara makes me an immediate contender against his and a few other stacked teams.

I think the value (especially the flip value) of Kamara is worth more than JKD and 2.3

Also, I don't think the cliff of RBs is as young as 26, especially ones that don't take a ton of hits.

The only top 10 fantasy RB over 26 is Derrick Henry who just turned 27 a week ago. In the top 20, you have guys like Mike Davis, Melvin Gordon and Kenyan Drake who are all 27. Drake and Gordon already slowed down and Davis was a one hit wonder. I think Kamara doesn't fall off that cliff right away but age is currently undefeated against RBs.

[joeday]

This has been my reservation. I don’t think Kamara makes me an immediate contender against his and a few other stacked teams.

I think the value (especially the flip value) of Kamara is worth more than JKD and 2.3

Also, I don't think the cliff of RBs is as young as 26, especially ones that don't take a ton of hits.

The only top 10 fantasy RB over 26 is Derrick Henry who just turned 27 a week ago. In the top 20, you have guys like Mike Davis, Melvin Gordon and Kenyan Drake who are all 27. Drake and Gordon already slowed down and Davis was a one hit wonder. I think Kamara doesn't fall off that cliff right away but age is currently undefeated against RBs.

I think you and I have talked about this before, regarding the draft classes of the RBs that would be hitting that age and how weak they were (Gurley was the only elite one but he had chronic knee injuries regardless of age). I don't disagree age is undefeated but I don't think 26 is that age. I guess we will see when the RBs of that class turn 26 if they all fall off a cliff or not.

[psfox2010]

Value says Kamara but I don't invest in 26 year old RBs

This has been my reservation. I don’t think Kamara makes me an immediate contender against his and a few other stacked teams.

Typically I'm in agreement with this, but I don't view a 26 year old Kamara the same as a 26 year old Zeke or Henry simply due to workload history and his usage in their offense. I don't worry about age as much with him.