Two trade offers - One for CMC, one for Hilton

This is the place for team advice - should I make this trade, should I draft that player, etc.
ff330
Captain
Captain
Posts: 839
Joined: Sun Jun 16, 2013 2:36 pm

Two trade offers - One for CMC, one for Hilton

Postby ff330 » Wed Nov 04, 2020 2:40 pm

Team 4 in sig

Was offered Zeke and Aiyuk for CMC and Cam from a team that offered me Miles Sanders, Aiyuk, and Hunt 2 weeks ago. The team has been on a downhill slide now at 3-5 with the 5 straight losses coming after losing CMC. Dallas is a train wreck right now with Zeke as it's only strong player but hasn't done much the past 2 weeks. Aiyuk is looking good but it's early and Deebo is still out. Would really want to hang onto CMC after waiting all this time for him to hopefully return this week.

Hilton is a bit hurt and probably GTD this week but the offer was a 4th plus Harry for him. With him injured, I assumed the offering owner would back off but shot me the same deal today. Harry is still in concussion protocol but has been a disappointment so far just like Hilton.

Hilton went for a 4th by itself a few weeks ago in another one of my DFWC leagues and I was offered him in another for a 2nd last week, which I turned down. Not quite sure of his value right now.

Any input??
12 team/PPR

1
QB - Mahomes
RB- Jacobs, Pierce, Penny, Mostert, Singletary, Wilson, Mckinnon, Moss, Foreman, Mitchell
WR - Kupp, Waddle, Lockett, Marquise Brown, OBJ
TE - Kincaid

2021/2012 league champion

2
QB - Dak, GSmith
RB - Swift, Mattison, White, Mostert, Gibbs, Foreman, Mitchell, D. Cook
WR - AJB, Kupp, Kirk, C.Samuel, JWilliams, OBJ, Ross
TE - Kittle, Ferguson

3
QB - Allen, Tua
RB - Kamara, AJones, Walker, Chandler, Pierce, Akers, JWilliams, Jaleel M., Mitchell
WR - Adams, Hopkins, Lockett, J. Watson
TE - Kraft, Dulcich

4
QB - Allen, Burrow (IR)
RB - CMC, Kamara, Stevenson, J.Cook, Foreman, J.Wilson, Jaleel, Mitchell
WR - Diggs, Jeudy, Aiyuk, ARSB, MWilliams Mooney, Downs, N. Brown
TE - Kincaid, Engram

2023 league champion

5
QB - Mahomes, Cousins
RB - Chubb, AJones, Akers, Foreman, Moss, Penny, Jaleel, Mitchell, Gray
WR - Adams, MThomas, Waddle, GDavis, Mooney, JWilliams, Downs, Dell, Skyy, Ross
TE - Goedert

User avatar
Gator Sens
GOAT
GOAT
Posts: 53938
Joined: Wed Jan 24, 2018 11:17 am
Contact:

Re: Two trade offers - One for CMC, one for Hilton

Postby Gator Sens » Wed Nov 04, 2020 2:43 pm

I would hold CMC in the first deal.

The second deal comes down to how you view Harry vs Hilton at this stage of his career. Hilton is not a good asset anymore and I would rather gamble on Harry progressing, but that is looking unlikely at this point

ff330
Captain
Captain
Posts: 839
Joined: Sun Jun 16, 2013 2:36 pm

Re: Two trade offers - One for CMC, one for Hilton

Postby ff330 » Wed Nov 04, 2020 5:31 pm

Had planned on a reject of the CMC offer. I agree it's more of a question on Hilton as to what value does he have left and if Harry has more potential despite his head injury history. Right now it looks like a late 4th plus N'Keal. I keep waiting for Hilton to break out and be what he was 2 seasons ago.
12 team/PPR

1
QB - Mahomes
RB- Jacobs, Pierce, Penny, Mostert, Singletary, Wilson, Mckinnon, Moss, Foreman, Mitchell
WR - Kupp, Waddle, Lockett, Marquise Brown, OBJ
TE - Kincaid

2021/2012 league champion

2
QB - Dak, GSmith
RB - Swift, Mattison, White, Mostert, Gibbs, Foreman, Mitchell, D. Cook
WR - AJB, Kupp, Kirk, C.Samuel, JWilliams, OBJ, Ross
TE - Kittle, Ferguson

3
QB - Allen, Tua
RB - Kamara, AJones, Walker, Chandler, Pierce, Akers, JWilliams, Jaleel M., Mitchell
WR - Adams, Hopkins, Lockett, J. Watson
TE - Kraft, Dulcich

4
QB - Allen, Burrow (IR)
RB - CMC, Kamara, Stevenson, J.Cook, Foreman, J.Wilson, Jaleel, Mitchell
WR - Diggs, Jeudy, Aiyuk, ARSB, MWilliams Mooney, Downs, N. Brown
TE - Kincaid, Engram

2023 league champion

5
QB - Mahomes, Cousins
RB - Chubb, AJones, Akers, Foreman, Moss, Penny, Jaleel, Mitchell, Gray
WR - Adams, MThomas, Waddle, GDavis, Mooney, JWilliams, Downs, Dell, Skyy, Ross
TE - Goedert

CattiestDust
Combine Attendee
Combine Attendee
Posts: 16
Joined: Tue Oct 27, 2020 5:35 pm

Re: Two trade offers - One for CMC, one for Hilton

Postby CattiestDust » Wed Nov 04, 2020 7:00 pm

I wouldn't count on Hilton correcting course. The pick, even a 4th, seems like the most potential value, but even player for player I guess I'd rather have Harry because there's the age on his side, but he has looked not great.
Established '20
SF, .5 PPR, two W/R/T Flex

QB: L. Jackson, D. Watson, J. Goff, B. DiNucci, J. Eason
WR (2): K. Golladay, W. Fuller, T. Boyd, M. Brown, C. Kirk, P. Williams, D. Mooney, O. Zaccheaus, M. Callaway, K. Hill
RB (2): J. Conner, M. Gordon, D. Swift, R. Jones, J. McKinnon, J. Richard, R. Freeman, B. Snell, L. Bowden, R. Dowdle
TE (1): D. Goedert, I. Smith, L. Thomas, K. Warring, J. Deguara


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: BearDown34, Bing [Bot], BucBuc, Google [Bot], Last Place, Viking386 and 65 guests