Huge deal in a 16 team league

[joeday]

In a 16 team PPR league (NOT super flex), which side would you take?

Give: Tua, Miles Sanders, Mike Evans, Deebo Samuel
Get: Baker Mayfield, Dalvin Cook, Chris Godwin

The only issue I have with the deal is in week 9 when Wentz is on bye that also happens to be when Baker is on bye so my QB situation would be Andy Dalton or DiNucci if he is the starter. If this was a 12 team league losing Tua wouldn’t even phase me.

Thoughts guys?

[Gator Sens]

Cook and Godwin for me, but it's very close due to the importance of depth in a 16 team league.

[Krypto_King]

Tua side but pretty close/ even. Maybe Cook if you're in it to win it

[MyTeam]

I like the Tua side but I am low on Cook and Mayfield. Cook can't stay healthy for playoffs

[joeday]

For additional context, if I make the deal, this is what my team would look like:

QB - Carson Wentz, Baker Mayfield, Jalen Hurts, Andy Dalton, Ben DiNucci
RB - Dalvin Cook, Josh Jacobs, David Montgomery, Devontae Booker, DeeJay Dallas, Adrian Peterson
WR - Chris Godwin, Cooper Kupp, Justin Jefferson, Sterling Shepard, John Brown, Scott Miller
TE - Darren Waller, Trey Burton, Logan Thomas

We start 1QB, 2RB, 2WR, 1FLEX, 1TE, 1K, 1D

[murphysxm]

based on it being a 16 teamer, I want the side that is healthy and provides more depth.

[Rustycage]

A lot of health concerns on both sides, but I would take Cook and Godwin side.

[joeday]

based on it being a 16 teamer, I want the side that is healthy and provides more depth.

Can you be more specific haha. Sanders, Deebo are both out...Cook looks back this week and Godwin should be back soon.

[joeday]

any more thoughts on this trade? At this point I am so torn I need someone to push me one way or the other lol

[dblj1199]

To me it all comes down to where your team stands overall, contender or pretender. With such a big league I usually would lean towards overall depth. Also what are the other qb's on your roster? In a nutshell I'd want the Cook side slightly, and it's a VERY slight edge.

[CL3VELANDBR0WNS]

I think I'd stick with the Tua side because it's better for the long-term and your team is good enough to survive Sander's absence and Evans getting phased out for no reason. Tua has a few rough spots the rest of the way but also some crush matchups..... he may be better than Mayfield who hopefully won't have to throw so much every week as he did last week.

[jobiegermano]

Cook is a special player. Take the best player in the trade. He has 4 TDs today. Take the Cook side!

[sloth8u]

Not a sanders fan at his price and have him very overrated by the masses right now. Evans and godwin a push for me. Dalvin> sanders, deebo for me. Concerns for both qbs...meh

[abloom]

Cook and Godwin easily since you have Wentz