Interesting trade

[Gator Sens]

12 team, .5 PPR start: 1 QB, 1 RB, 1WR, 3 Flex and a TE.

Contender

Give Mixon + Godwin for Elliot.

My typical lineup outside of byes and all:
Mahomes
Kamara
Ridley
Jonnu Smith
Aaron Jones
and any combo of: Godwin, Lamb, Jeudy, Mixon, Higgins, Ruggs, Mike Williams, Justin Jefferson and so on...

Thoughts?

[Cowboysfan33]

That’s tough for me, I normally love Zeke but with the state of the oline, both starting tackles out for the season, rookie center starting plus Dak out, then Zeke is fumbling like crazy, it’s a ok deal but I don’t think it’s a deal that you have to make. I’d probably pass.

[jcc6fd]

He’s an upgrade over both pieces but I think this is an overpay. Probably what it would take to get him. I don’t have any problem getting out of Mixon but Godwin is a bigger pill to swallow.

[FantasyFreak]

NO!!! You didn't even spell his name right, that's a sign.

[Gator Sens]

Thank you for the input all, I appreciate it.

[jjleurquin]

I would hold. Not a terrible deal but Kamara Jones and Mixon is a solid trio. Considering how long RBs last compared to WRs Godwin might end up being the most valuable piece. I think this is selling low on Godwin and I think he'll be fine going forward.

[JessterC]

That is an overpay for Zeke

[BucBuc]

As it stands I'd pass even tho I'm all about selling Mixon and Godwin but your just not getting enough back... maybe get a Crowder type added or a pick

[gpaok]

Given you have Kamara and Jones, havIng Mixon as third string is not bad. Godwin is about to (hopefully) return to his normal last year levels, so seems like an overpay. Unfortunately though that’s what happens with RB trades right?

Other thoughts:
I doubt AB affects Godwin’s value so I think you have a top WR in your lineup
Elliott will struggle this year due to Dak so not the super elite he was the first 4 games.

[Rustycage]

I don't think I could do it. Godwin feels like he is pretty low value right now, so I'd hold.

[afrye1]

Given you have Kamara and Jones, havIng Mixon as third string is not bad. Godwin is about to (hopefully) return to his normal last year levels, so seems like an overpay. Unfortunately though that’s what happens with RB trades right?

Other thoughts:
I doubt AB affects Godwin’s value so I think you have a top WR in your lineup
Elliott will struggle this year due to Dak so not the super elite he was the first 4 games.

This. All of this

[Dibbles]

I would hold. Not a terrible deal but Kamara Jones and Mixon is a solid trio. Considering how long RBs last compared to WRs Godwin might end up being the most valuable piece. I think this is selling low on Godwin and I think he'll be fine going forward.

Agree with this.

[jobiegermano]

I think your hesitation is because like everyone else you think Mixon is finally about to have that year we’ve always expected, but I’ve been saying that fir so many years now. He should have a decent second half, but his O-line situation is as bad as Zeke’s plus he has a terrible organization and I just think Zeke is an upgrade with at least just as many years left.

Full disclosure, I traded away Mixon this year after holding him since he came into the league. I am feeling a little worried I got out at the wrong time, but here he is hurt again. I also sold Godwin a few years ago and probably for less than I should have, so I definitely know what it feels like to let them both go.

The thing is I don’t think Godwin will be as good with Brady. Brady just doesn’t keep WRs afloat, almost never has. The cowboys might lean on Zeke even more this year and you are contending.

All three players are in a down right now. I think Zeke is the best player in the trade. I like to get the best player in a trade.

I think you have enough WR talent with Lamb and JJ etc so go ahead and grab Zeke!

[J. Edgar]

Definitely an overpay but to be able to start Kamara, Elliot and Jones is awfully tempting.

[gpaok]

Another thought I also had Elliot will have a higher value next year when Dak is back so if you worry about Mixon you might be better off with the trade next year! But it wouldn’t help you that much this year!