Need quick advice on this offer I just got!?!?

[shalna]

12 team .5ppr was offered Jonathan Taylor + Brandin Cooks for Carson + Arob + Henderson should I make this deal?

It’s a 2 keeper league. I only care about winning this year tho.


QB-Rodgers

WR-Adams

WR-A-Rob

WR-Ridley

RB-Conner

RB-Henry

TE-Hurst

Flex-Carson

Bench

RB-David Johnson

WR-Diontae Johnson

RB-Henderson

TE-Ebron

TE-Gesicki

RB-Hyde

TE-Logan Thomas

[Gator Sens]

Long term, I would lock up Taylor here.

[Dibbles]

If only a 2 keeper league and you only care about winning this year, I'd keep ARob/Carson/Henderson. They are better than JT and Cooks for this year.

[shalna]

Long term, I would lock up Taylor here.

I’m not worried about long term. I play to win by the year. That’s why I said I’m only worried about winning this year

[shalna]

If only a 2 keeper league and you only care about winning this year, I'd keep ARob/Carson/Henderson. They are better than JT and Cooks for this year.

I see a lot of things saying Taylor could be a catalyst to lead teams to a championship run for this year

[Dibbles]

If only a 2 keeper league and you only care about winning this year, I'd keep ARob/Carson/Henderson. They are better than JT and Cooks for this year.

I see a lot of things saying Taylor could be a catalyst to lead teams to a championship run for this year

Not my point, but if you like JT that much then do the deal. My point is Carson vs JT for this year is probably close, maybe JT wins out but Carson is a consistently solid producer outside of injury. Then ARob >>>>> Cooks, and you get Henderson as insurance. The total points for this season (since this is your focus) is very likely on the Carson/ARob side, regardless of how great JT is.

[shalna]

If only a 2 keeper league and you only care about winning this year, I'd keep ARob/Carson/Henderson. They are better than JT and Cooks for this year.

I see a lot of things saying Taylor could be a catalyst to lead teams to a championship run for this year

Not my point, but if you like JT that much then do the deal. My point is Carson vs JT for this year is probably close, maybe JT wins out but Carson is a consistently solid producer outside of injury. Then ARob >>>>> Cooks, and you get Henderson as insurance. The total points for this season (since this is your focus) is very likely on the Carson/ARob side, regardless of how great JT is.

Most likely yes. But at the same time I’m looking to upgrade my weekly starting lineup too. I have Diontae n Johnson just sitting on my bench

[Dibbles]

I see a lot of things saying Taylor could be a catalyst to lead teams to a championship run for this year

Not my point, but if you like JT that much then do the deal. My point is Carson vs JT for this year is probably close, maybe JT wins out but Carson is a consistently solid producer outside of injury. Then ARob >>>>> Cooks, and you get Henderson as insurance. The total points for this season (since this is your focus) is very likely on the Carson/ARob side, regardless of how great JT is.

Most likely yes. But at the same time I’m looking to upgrade my weekly starting lineup too. I have Diontae n Johnson just sitting on my bench

Yes, I realize your goals and roster situation. You are either starting JT/Connor/Diontae, with Cooks and David Johnson as backup . . . or you are starting Carson/Connor/Arob, with Henderson, David Johnson and Diontae as backup. I prefer option 2, but go for JT, it sounds like you are definitely leaning that way.

[shalna]

Not my point, but if you like JT that much then do the deal. My point is Carson vs JT for this year is probably close, maybe JT wins out but Carson is a consistently solid producer outside of injury. Then ARob >>>>> Cooks, and you get Henderson as insurance. The total points for this season (since this is your focus) is very likely on the Carson/ARob side, regardless of how great JT is.

Most likely yes. But at the same time I’m looking to upgrade my weekly starting lineup too. I have Diontae n Johnson just sitting on my bench

Yes, I realize your goals and roster situation. You are either starting JT/Connor/Diontae, with Cooks and David Johnson as backup . . . or you are starting Carson/Connor/Arob, with Henderson, David Johnson and Diontae as backup. I prefer option 2, but go for JT, it sounds like you are definitely leaning that way.

I’m not leaning that way at all. I’m asking who you would package up to try n upgrade my lineup. For Taylor or any player

[shalna]

.....

[jomaed]

Who puts up more points this year? Arob/Carson or JT/Dionte. I have no clue, but thats your answer.

[shalna]

Who puts up more points this year? Arob/Carson or JT/Dionte. I have no clue, but thats your answer.

Hence why I’m asking for opinions

[BigBawseRoss]

what about these first 2 weeks makes you want to pay allen robinson in order to turn chris carson into JT?

carson has 170 yards and 3 score, JT has 190 and 1.

you are paying a top flight WR for a perceived upgrade.

[shalna]

what about these first 2 weeks makes you want to pay allen robinson in order to turn chris carson into JT?

carson has 170 yards and 3 score, JT has 190 and 1.

you are paying a top flight WR for a perceived upgrade.

Robinson hasn’t looked top flight and Taylor has 4th easiest ever schedule remaining. Carson in a pass heavy offense and has injury concerns

[SteveMaddensShoes]

what about these first 2 weeks makes you want to pay allen robinson in order to turn chris carson into JT?

carson has 170 yards and 3 score, JT has 190 and 1.

you are paying a top flight WR for a perceived upgrade.

Robinson hasn’t looked top flight and Taylor has 4th easiest ever schedule remaining. Carson in a pass heavy offense and has injury concerns

"You sound like you already know what you want, Pam."

But Allen is top flight. It's only 2 weeks and he has somewhat of a track record of being a low end wr1/high end wr2. Don't let 2 weeks fool you. He isn't Julio by any means but he has the talent to be a wr2 this year no doubt.

I lean the JT side, but I'd say the easiest schedule ever will get harder if Rivers continues to look bad. Defenses will respect the pass less and less.

I'd rather have JT/Diontae though...I think...