Chubb = Dobbins +?

[PBFalcon]

Team in sig. 10 team. Standard (nonppr).

I have Chubb. I don't really like that he is sharing the backfield with Hunt. I don't really like trading one player for 2, especially since my team is kinda full right now. But the owners if Swift and Dobbins are both Browns fans have suggested that they would give me their Dobbins or Swift + for my Chubb.
The swift owner verbally offered me Swift + Reagor for my Chubb.
The Dobbins owner hasn't offered anything yet. What would you ask for on top of Dobbins? His assets that I would interested in are his late 2021 1st, Sutton, Golladay, AJ Brown.
Thanks.

[FantasyFreak]

I don't think most people would give up much on top, TBH. If you could get the first, that would be more than I would expect you to get.

[Gator Sens]

I'm guessing a 2nd is the best you could hope for on top, but its risky based on what Chubb has shown.

[M-Dub]

Unless the Dobbins owner is willing to add one of the players you listed (highly unlikely), I would take that Swift offer pretty easily. I don’t see much if any difference between Chubb and Swift, and with your starting requirements and ridiculous RB depth, adding Reagor could definitely help you on bye weeks or if one or more of your WRs gets hurt.

[dblj1199]

Your team is ridiculously deep, so I'd go to the Dobbins owner and tell him you have a offer on the table of two high end young players for Chubb, what is he willing to offer for him on top of JK? See what he comes back with. But with your roster you can afford to give up Chubb if you get a big return to build more depth / and high end depth.

[cvbuc]

I would clearly and absolutely target Dobbins over Swift.
I think by year's end - Dobbins > Chubb... but he clearly is not at the moment.

I would try and get Dobbins and the 1st.
I would go as far as adding my 2nd on the Chubb side to get it done.
But that's just how much I believe in Dobbins in that offense

[Alex116]

Unless the Dobbins owner is willing to add one of the players you listed (highly unlikely), I would take that Swift offer pretty easily. I don’t see much if any difference between Chubb and Swift, and with your starting requirements and ridiculous RB depth, adding Reagor could definitely help you on bye weeks or if one or more of your WRs gets hurt.

We haven't even seen Swift play an NFL snap yet. I can't def don't have Chubb = Swift, at least not yet! Having said that, Swift was the consensus #1 RB in the rookie/draft rankings around this time last year. Reagor is def a nice piece and not just some random extra! Either way, i love Dobbins and would try to work a deal out for him over Swift.

One thing to keep in mind is the fact that we don't know what sort of split we'll see in Cleveland. It's a new coach and he may lean on Chubb more than we think? Chubb is still very under rated as a runner and if not for Hunt's presence i think he'd have a ton more hype.

[Favrezilla]

I’m probably not trading Chubb for any of this personally. Too light for a proven stud.

[Finfansteve]

Earlier this week I offered Chubb to the dobbins owner and asked for a 2021 1st and dobbins for Chubb. Immediately it was rejected with no counter

[TheGoat21]

I think this is a bad time to trade Chubb. People are thinking the worst post Hunt extension.

But if you can get Dobbins and the first I would take it. I have Dobbins over Swift.