Chubb + for Taylor +

[RedBeardNW]

Today I was offered an interesting trade. The trade is: Chubb, Diggs, and Antonio Gibson for Taylor, Jefferson, and Hockenson. What side do you like best? Would you add anything else to move Chubb?

[Gator Sens]

I'm not a Diggs fan at all, but this is the Chubb side for me. Two established piece with value. I really like Taylor, but I would stick with Chubb if contending/competing.

[HughHoney]

Taylor/Jefferson side for me

[never_punts]

I'm not a Diggs fan at all, but this is the Chubb side for me. Two established piece with value. I really like Taylor, but I would stick with Chubb if contending/competing.

x2

[thebeast]

I’m surprised by the poll. Chubb side easily. The other side is gambling. With Chubb you already have a 1st/2nd round startup pick. JT owners are hoping he becomes that and there is no doubt that he has the potential to, but potential never equals certainty. There are a ton of RBs that never lived up to their potential or hype, I’d keep the sure thing. I would want all three for Chubb alone based on current values

[FantasyFreak]

Chubb and JT are close for me. Chubb is a sure thing, but JT is such a great prospect, and is almost certainly going to be a workhorse. He's 4 years younger, so the added gamble could easily pay off. ADP isn't that far off as it stands, and JT could easily be ahead of Chubb next year. I love both backs. I'd much prefer Hock to Gibson. It's close, more risk on the JT side, but more upside, too.

[Mjvb5]

Chubb>=JT+hockenson
Diggs>jefferson
Plus a free gipson. This is chubb side pretty easily for me

[Blackout]

Chubb is a proven guy, Diggs is able to do some things. Others are speculation even if Taylor is a great prospect.

Chubb side