Which Add on do I ask for in the trade?

[Riders4Ever]

I am in the middle of trade talks in a 14 team ppr dynasty and we have all parts of the deal negotiated except one. With the recent Guice news (he's an idiot), my RB depth has taken a hit. The other owner has agreed to add one of the following to what I will get : Boston Scott, Duke Johnson or Damien Harris. I am a contending team, so which one do I ask for?

I have considered asking for Hayden Hurst because I have Howard, Thomas and Herndon as my TEs, but that ask will probably re-open negotiations and scrap the deal we have mostly negotiated. Hurst might not be that big of a deal because Blake Jarwin is a FA in this league.

[Gator Sens]

Harris for me. Michel will miss six weeks and Bolden opted out. Harris will get a serious look.

[moishetreats]

Harris.

All three are second on their depth chart. Only Harris has a real chance of moving to the top and staying at the top even without an injury to the #1 guy.

@Gator Sens: You're not exactly correct on Michel. He was put on the PUP list for training camp, but that does NOT mean that he will start the season on the PUP list. A player on the PUP list in training camp may be taken off at any time once he passes a physical. That being said, it is another reason to prefer Harris: the RB in front of him is already dealing with an injury. But, we don't know if Michel will be active Week 1 or not.

[Gator Sens]

Harris.

All three are second on their depth chart. Only Harris has a real chance of moving to the top and staying at the top even without an injury to the #1 guy.

@Gator Sens: You're not exactly correct on Michel. He was put on the PUP list for training camp, but that does NOT mean that he will start the season on the PUP list. A player on the PUP list in training camp may be taken off at any time once he passes a physical. That being said, it is another reason to prefer Harris: the RB in front of him is already dealing with an injury. But, we don't know if Michel will be active Week 1 or not.

I appreciate that clarification on Michel. Here I was all pumped as a Harris owner who just lost Guice ha ha.

[pnrsteelers]

Easy its Harris!

[bennythedog93]

Harris! I’d hurry and get that done!!



John

[jwb32]

Harris

[moishetreats]

Harris.

All three are second on their depth chart. Only Harris has a real chance of moving to the top and staying at the top even without an injury to the #1 guy.

@Gator Sens: You're not exactly correct on Michel. He was put on the PUP list for training camp, but that does NOT mean that he will start the season on the PUP list. A player on the PUP list in training camp may be taken off at any time once he passes a physical. That being said, it is another reason to prefer Harris: the RB in front of him is already dealing with an injury. But, we don't know if Michel will be active Week 1 or not.

I appreciate that clarification on Michel. Here I was all pumped as a Harris owner who just lost Guice ha ha.

Hah!

For whatever it's worth, I'd rather have Harris over Michel anyway. I think that you'll end up glad he's on your bench.

[OhSnapItsAnt]

If you’re looking for an RB to start in a win now.. in ppr this is easily Duke.. so many targets available with a bunch of injury prone guys on the team. Duke will have a significant role this year. I’m absolutely sure of it.

To me this depends on your RB room.. Harris doesn’t help you win now. Michel isn’t going anywhere this year, and even if he misses a few games. There’s no way he’ll be startable. Don’t get me wrong, I love Harris for a stash but there’s no way he helps you win NOW