Give guice, receive rojo tua?

[zarathustra]

I'm a guice truther, but this offer was made by a leaguemate.....

[Gator Sens]

You are in decent shape at QB. I like Jones II a lot the next few years and think he makes a jump, but I would hold Guice as a truther too.

[Z$$$]

Keep Guice. Think he’s the better talent. Could bite you though with another injury

[dblj1199]

Too me it comes down to Tua and Baker long term. Guice and RoJo to me are pretty even, both could break out, but it wouldn't surprise me if both are on another team in 2021 battling for a roster spot. So if your really high on Tua and think his upside is much higher than Goff and Baker I'd pull the trigger. If you think Tua is going to flop, hold Guice and pass on the deal. Personally I like Tua, imo he sits until after mid year, is able to get fully healthy and then he plays down the stretch. I'd go for it.

[moishetreats]

IMO, Tua > Guice
Rojo > Guice

I get being a truther, but the odds of it ever happening for Guice are extraordinarily low. Holding is one thing. Passing up on a great offer is another.

[FantasyFoosball]

Guice for me. I traded Rojo during last season for Guice, and in a 1QB league, Tua doesn't do much for me here. I think it's fair either way, but I like Guice the best of the bunch.

[cvbuc]

I'd accept.
I like Rojo more than Guice. People are overestimating Vaughn and ignoring the huge leap Rojo made between years 1 and 2 and he's still only 22. Give me the upside of Tua on top of that... I'll take it.
There are VERY FEW RBs historically that have had success after zero production in their first two years like Guice. It would make for a great story if he succeeds... it really would, but it is so rare it's very hard to bank on.