Dynasty League Football Forum

12 teams, PPR

This depends on your roster, and starting requirements. Would be helpful to know more here.

Without having that information, I'd lean the Guice side here, as he is the best piece for me in the deal. I have him slightly ahead of Lindsay.

As is, I would gamble on Guice and his massive upside here.

WRs are Sutton, Godwin, Keenan, Cooks, Raegor, A Miller, Shenault so losing Brown shouldn't hurt much.

Guice side easy for me. I cannot envision a world where John Brown stays more than a fringe WR2. I think the concerns over Guice are valid but overplayed and buy him everywhere I find him devalued.

I think its pretty even but seeing John Brown and Lindsay both perform well the past couple seasons makes me lean towards that. John Brown was a high end WR2 and now in his 2nd year with the team and nobody seems to realize that.

metalmat wrote: ↑Wed Jul 01, 2020 10:52 pm I think its pretty even but seeing John Brown and Lindsay both perform well the past couple seasons makes me lean towards that. John Brown was a high end WR2 and now in his 2nd year with the team and nobody seems to realize that.

and he got recruited over and is a year older. He's a year by year play without much upside left. Lindsay is a 26yo UDFA who just lost his job. If you want safety in a deep league you can take that side but Guice is likely a better short and long-term play, plus a free scratch off 3rd rounder.

Krypto_King wrote: ↑Wed Jul 01, 2020 11:04 pm

metalmat wrote: ↑Wed Jul 01, 2020 10:52 pm I think its pretty even but seeing John Brown and Lindsay both perform well the past couple seasons makes me lean towards that. John Brown was a high end WR2 and now in his 2nd year with the team and nobody seems to realize that.

and he got recruited over and is a year older. He's a year by year play without much upside left. Lindsay is a 26yo UDFA who just lost his job. If you want safety in a deep league you can take that side but Guice is likely a better short and long-term play, plus a free scratch off 3rd rounder.

Like I said I like both and could go either way. I'll agree there is much more upside with Guice.

metalmat wrote: ↑Wed Jul 01, 2020 10:52 pm I think its pretty even but seeing John Brown and Lindsay both perform well the past couple seasons makes me lean towards that. John Brown was a high end WR2 and now in his 2nd year with the team and nobody seems to realize that.

I realize that. But i also realize that Diggs is in town now and that can't really be good for John Brown can it?

metalmat wrote: ↑Wed Jul 01, 2020 10:52 pm I think its pretty even but seeing John Brown and Lindsay both perform well the past couple seasons makes me lean towards that. John Brown was a high end WR2 and now in his 2nd year with the team and nobody seems to realize that.

Melvin Gordon sucks and I think Lindsay will be his equal if not better in fantasy on fewer touches; but from draft capital and frame alone, he doesn't have Guice's upside

John Brown was a redraft target for me last year and I was happy to have him as a depth piece who I could plug in at WR2

But he is being correctly slept on for one big reason and his name is Stefon Diggs. I don't see Buffalo having the volume to back 2 fantasy relevant WRs enough to make them consistent starters