Which side ? CMC trade

[cane]

In 1qb,no flex, 18 roster spot shallow league,12 team .ive been offered
CMC
Tj hockenson
Darwin Thompson
2021 3rd round pick

For my
Gurley
A.robinson
D.williams
2020 pick1.01
2020 pick 2.01
2021 1st Rounder
2021 2nd rounder
2021 3rd rounder

Good trade?

[Gator Sens]

CMC side.

[Yarnith]

I am apparently down on overpays for superstars and I am down again here. I think CMC is a 1500yds overrall 10td player year to year and no way do I pay Arob, Gurley and CEH for that as well as the rest of 2 years worth of top picks.

[moishetreats]

I am apparently down on overpays for superstars and I am down again here. I think CMC is a 1500yds overrall 10td player year to year and no way do I pay Arob, Gurley and CEH for that as well as the rest of 2 years worth of top picks.

^^This!!

The ONLY exception is if your roster is stacked, you need to cut players anyway, and this is literally a depth-for-starter play. Given the shallow leagues, it might be the case. But, it's still hard for me to imagine that any team has so much depth that Robinson, Gurley, and 1.01 are depth pieces.

[Hahaclintondix]

It would help to see the rest of the roster, but in a shallow league where you’re likely able to pick up a lot of fringe type guys I’d take the stud in CMC.

[FantasyFoosball]

It would be helpful to know how many teams are in the league, and what your roster is.

But the fact that it's a shallow league with no flex positions, that tells me that studs rule the day, which makes me want to go with CMC here.

18 roster spots isn't a lot, which makes me want to go with CMC here even more.

But again, would be helpful to have more info.

[cane]

12. Team league

[BeeziBad]

CMC side. i'd need a more reliable option than gurley and a younger option than arob.

[Zacsby]

I am apparently down on overpays for superstars and I am down again here. I think CMC is a 1500yds overrall 10td player year to year and no way do I pay Arob, Gurley and CEH for that as well as the rest of 2 years worth of top picks.

He's gone for 1800+ the past two years. Also 100+ receptions. Having CMC is having a borderline RB1 and a borderline WR1 in a single slot. It can not be understated how big a deal that is in a league with shallow lineups.

[srlarson]

assuming since you have the 1.01 you are not a contender.....keep your 5 picks over the next two years to rebuild......if you acquired in a trade and have a chance to win....push your chips in the middle.

[cane]

assuming since you have the 1.01 you are not a contender.....keep your 5 picks over the next two years to rebuild......if you acquired in a trade and have a chance to win....push your chips in the middle.

I consider myself a contender. I was rattled with injuries last year and barely missed playoffs. 1-6 picks are random drawings.. I didn’t have worst record

[MFundercover]

Not enough for me to give up Christian Mccaffery.

[StripesOfKC]

I am okay with Arob but would definitely need a younger, steadier piece than Gurley to move CMC

[Adam_172]

CMC easily for me. Always take the stud unless you need depth.

[cane]

Wow even Steven.. curious if anyone else has an opinion..I made the trade to acquire cmc.. did I win or lose?